The Philosophy of Everything — Part II: On Metaphysics, Chapter 8: Free Will or Determinism?
The discussion in this chapter helps us assess whether God predetermines our lives and if we go with the flow or have the will to change our destiny according to our wishes.
The topics we cover here are:
- Free Will
- Determinism
Reality is like an interactive live sports broadcast with many vantage points. It is not like a movie or a book, where there is no scope for changing anything while watching or reading. We chose the camera angle, the audio language, subtitles and many more variables.
The benefit is that we actively intervene in the world using our will. We may consciously favour and be against things that we like and dislike. Occasionally, we change the direction of our lives, modify the path to the truth, and make decisions to improve our survival chances. Of course, many situations pop up that can corner us. Nevertheless, we manage to pull through these unforeseen circumstances over time.
The only impediment in our lives is our mental modifications. Our past karma enslaves our present thoughts, words and actions. Both innate tendencies and acquired conditioning compound our problems. The freer we are from these mind modifications, the better our intervention capability.
We can plant a tree wherever and whenever. Nevertheless, it is beyond our control whether it becomes a tree or not. Even if we put in all our effort to ensure the plant grows into a tree, several factors beyond our control can go wrong.
The moment we attempt to control an intractable entity, we become miserable. We must stop such pursuits without any delay. Instead, we must circumvent the situations that reality throws at us.
We need not worry if there is a shortage of rainfall this year. There are alternative irrigation methods. Likewise, all the issues have solutions. We must solve the hindrances to the plant’s development into a tree. If, after all the effort, some untoward incident happens and the plant dies, we do not need to blame ourselves or the reality. We should remain optimistic and try again with the realization that the odds were not favouring the plant despite all our struggles. We must conduct a thorough study of the reasons behind failure to ensure that the responsibility does not lie in our shortcomings. Then, plant another and put in the same or more exertion again.
Likewise, life cannot be under the absolute authority of anyone, as there is always a degree of uncertainty. However, unlike any other creation, we have the consciousness and the capability to intervene and better our lives. The sooner we realize this, the faster we begin to liberate ourselves.
The eternal laws do not imply any absolute determinism. According to the prevailing conditions, energy manifests in various forms, abiding by these laws. As the circumstances keep changing, the causes and their effects keep varying. Hence, if we can study and master the events, we will be able to better manage these laws in our best interest to a large extent.
Imagine if we are bankrupt and stuck with mounting debt. We find ourselves in a situation that is not acceptable to us. So, the solution is to investigate the reasons behind our bankruptcy thoroughly. In a hypothetical scenario, by going through the finances, we understand that we have spent more than we earned over the year. It was a consequence of our decision to support a cousin’s cancer treatment.
Unfortunately, we did not cut down on our spending despite our income stagnating and expenses skyrocketing. As a result, our finances look terrible in a year, with our savings dried up. The solution is: to either trim our spending or get a new, better-paying job. Inferring the conditions that now constrain us, we may tweak them using our will and rescue ourselves from the clutches of determinism.
We limit determinism using our consciousness. The way we live is entirely our choice. Whether we live in heaven or hell is the result of our determination.
Of course, every person must face the consequences of their actions and follow the rules laid down by society. We can be sympathetic to the wrongdoing of a person, as their past conditions determine their present actions. However, through education, we must ensure that children become better people, not criminals. We must empower them to free their will and live consciously, abiding by the true nature of reality.
Living is exploring through a maze of perpetually bifurcating and intertwining probabilities. As long as we live harmonizing with reality, we have nothing to worry about in life. When we use our will virtuously within the parameters of actuality, it enriches our survival. If not, we will create more problems and threaten our existence.
There is no absolute free will. Both inanimate and the animate world, with the exemption of humans, do not possess them. We can make a dedicated effort to free our will in our case.
Freeing the will gives us the power to enhance our survival without any conditions forcing us to act in a particular way. Every moment, we must endeavour to evade the clutches of innate tendencies, acquired conditioning, and past karmas that trap us in life.
Our life will always be a journey to liberate our will from these trappings. We must continually persist in mastering our thoughts, words and actions. As a result, we may gradually release it from the effect of the modifications and their impact on our present karma. After liberation, we can live freely in the present at our true potential, fully engaging our consciousness.