The Philosophy of Everything — Part I: On Epistemology, Chapter 3: The Knowing Process
In this chapter, we will use examples from ordinary life to expand on the direct and indirect processes to draw sound conclusions. Studying various inferential and analytical reasoning techniques sharpens our critical thinking skills, allowing us to find correct information from reliable sources. As a conscious animal, it is vital to understand, for our survival, how we might arrive at facts through an objective procedure free of subjective preconceptions. Without knowledge, we cannot win over ignorance, the root cause of all problems.
The topics we cover here are:
- Beliefs, Hypothesis, Valid Hypothesis, Theory, Knowledge and Facts
- The Four Conditions of Knowing
- Direct Knowing
- Indirect Knowing –
- Inferential Process (Whole and Part, Substance and Quality, Individual and Classes),
- Dialectic Process (Testimony and Debate),
- Analytical Process (Scientific Analysis, Controlled Experiments and Mathematics)
Beliefs are wild guesses that explain an observation meaningfully to a layperson without validation. However, beliefs can be the natural progress of science.
A “hypothesis” is an intelligent guess with a plausible explanation, testable with the proper scientific methods.
A hypothesis predicts that gravity bends light. It becomes a “valid hypothesis” after validation.
We must examine all our beliefs objectively and draw conclusions based on the evidence. Ignore them if they are non-verifiable. If verifiable, we subject the hypothesis to a valid process of knowing. We need not discard it if it is invalid. We can change and retest it until we develop a “theory” that is the basic unit of knowledge. A group of interrelated valid hypotheses constitute a theory.
A “fact” is a short derivative of knowledge for people to assimilate quickly. Some information can be inconceivable to a layperson. So, we must reduce it to smaller statements that everyone can understand.
We should not define “knowledge” as “a justified belief ”. It creates unnecessary loopholes vulnerable to exploitation. Flat Earth is a belief that many people attempt to justify in various ways. People tend to think that there is nothing more to know. They create a belief system and rationalize everything simplistically within the limits of their trivial understanding. These simple justifications make sense and spread like wildfire. Unfortunately, the facts progress at a snail’s pace. We can easily convince anyone that the sun orbits us by asking them to observe. Educating people about the truth takes time and effort.
There are two criteria to know. Firstly, the description of an idea should be a fact that is free of misconception. Secondly, the correlation between two or more ideas must be accurate. One fact describes the sun as producing sunlight, whereas another can define the day as a period with sunlight. The precise correlation between these two ideas is that the day has sunlight.
These processes help us understand all our experiences and result in “knowing”. Only humans have this capacity to perceive and categorize our experiences in memory. When a child grows, this ability develops in complexity and helps them thrive in the world. It empowers us by sharing among ourselves profound insight into the environment.
Knowing implies four conditions: an observer, an idea under observation, the resulting conclusion and the means of validation.
A brother finds his sister on the roadside, lying next to her bicycle. Using direct perception (means), the brother (observer) sees the sister on the roadside (observation). He believes that she has fallen (conclusion).
It is valid because the brother is directly perceiving it. Seeing him rush, the sister reveals that she is only resting. Immediately, he realizes the incorrect assessment of the situation. His conclusion becomes invalid.
Our judgments can be credible or not because of our habit of observing casually and deciding before examining them thoroughly. On an evening stroll, we see a snake and quickly move away. Later, we notice it is dead. Our instincts respond to saving our lives without waiting for validation in such circumstances.
The brother’s self identifies with his sister and activates his involuntary instincts. If it is a random girl, the seriousness of the situation will determine his response. Occasionally, it may depend on his conscience or whether the girl could be a potential love interest. Suppose it turns out to be a man and his friend, he will probably make fun of him and share the pictures on social media.
There are two ways of knowing: directly and indirectly.
Direct Knowing
The direct way of knowing is through perception. It is the ability to discern between those experiences that arrive through the senses.
After work, Yousuf drives back home.
It is through seeing that he knows his house. He does not confuse it with another because the building matches the memory of his home.
Sana, his daughter, rushes to embrace and kiss him. The touch realizes the warmth of her love.
He identifies what he is drinking as tea or coffee from the taste.
While relaxing, he smells a gas leak and learns that his daughter did not shut the knob properly. He plugs the leak and prevents a tragedy.
Listening to his boss, he assesses the displeasure in his voice for not submitting a report. He promises to deliver it in the morning.
We understand the world around us through direct observations.
Later, Yousuf decides to go for a stroll. If he sees a snake, he instantly moves away, poisonous or not. Instincts operate through our direct perception, even if it is a dead snake. He does not take its picture and search online to identify it correctly as a threat or non-threat. His instincts respond to protect his life. Nevertheless, if he is a reptilian expert, he may know the snake and pet it.
Validation through perception is troublesome because a different person can experience the same thing diversely. It is not necessarily valid.
The east is where the sun rises, and the west is where it sets. Yet, the sun circles for several weeks in the Arctic Circle.
We have two experiences: a shifting and a circling sun. Both experiences are contradictory. The earth rotates on its axis, resulting in day and night, while its tilt is the cause of the circling sun. So, the knowledge is that our sun does neither shift nor travel in circles.
Hence, all external perceptions must pass the validation test because they can be deceptive.
However, internal perception is tricky as it is a subjective truth. People feel the same movie differently, as the experience depends on each individual’s unique mind modifications. An external perception, on the other hand, can only be objective.
We need to think logically about our internal encounters and make an accurate sense of them.
Doctors set the normal range of sugar levels in the blood by averaging the data of thousands of people. Perhaps averaging our experiences can also bring us closer to objective truth.
Psychologists sometimes designate normal behaviours by averaging the evaluations of many clients. Similarly, using statistics, we can add objectivity to our subjective experiences.
Sitting alone on a beach doing nothing is joyful for some and crazy for others. After a survey, we can state internal perceptions in percentages, like seventy-two per cent of people consider doing nothing as relaxing.
Human senses are subject to errors due to various limitations. A stick in water may appear bent due to an optical illusion. Likewise, our perception becomes invalid for many reasons.
Firstly, it happens due to wrong perceptions, like mistaking a rope for a snake at night. We must understand that the correct perception of the idea always exists, independent of the observer. The truth exists, even if the observer experiences it as a snake.
A person with jaundice will see a white flower as yellow. Secondly, it can occur due to defective sense organs. Similarly, a nose block will prevent us from perceiving a gas leak.
Lastly, it can happen when we imagine ideas that do not exist.
Believing the sex stories put out by the publicity team, supermarket manager Adam Malone lusts after the well-known coquettish movie star Sharon Fields. Adam possesses an imaginary idea of Sharon put out in public to keep her in the limelight. He and three other men kidnap her, thinking she will voluntarily satisfy their desires. Eventually, they rape her. All her pleas that the publicity is untrue fall on deaf ears.
The world is full of fake stories to promote one or other agendas. They repeat a lie numerous times, giving the impression of truth. Adam may be a criminal; however, his delusions originated from a lie marketed as truth.
Unfortunately, many people believe these stories and undermine our democratic process. We have seen how spreading harmful conspiracy theories risked our health during the pandemic by discrediting science. Hence, it is time for us to seize the ability to discriminate between real and bogus ideas.
It does not mean that imagining is wrong. The positive use of imagination is critical to our success and problem-solving. We analyze seemingly unrelated ideas to create a new solution or improve an existing one. It is the ideal way to progress effectively. We have to use our imagination more often to become more creative and innovative.
Occasionally, it is possible not to perceive an idea. In that case, there is only ignorance and no mistake.
A boy finds a bucket containing a tasteless and odourless transparent liquid in the storeroom and perceives it as water. He uses it to wash the batting pads and later hangs them to dry. The next day, he notices they are denaturing. Seeing the tantrums of the boy, the father investigates. Inadvertently, the boy wrongly assumes the dilute sulphuric acid is water.
So, an idea that is not perceivable due to ignorance does not become the locus of invalid perception or fall in the category of a mistake.
Indirect Knowing
To know the wind or probe gravity, we investigate its effects on the world. Direct knowing does not provide complete knowledge, mainly beyond perception. Therefore, we require a suggestive process such as inferential, dialectic or analytic for indirect knowing.
Inferential Process
“Inference” is the process of knowing something without actually experiencing it. It is done by connecting different ideas. We can also deduce knowledge by understanding the correct correlation of ideas. We know that fire causes smoke. So, if there is smoke, we infer there must be a fire.
There is a systematic method for testing inferential validity through a chain of arguments. Fact, reason, example, application and conclusion are the five premises we use to help people with inferential reasoning.
In a hypothetical circumstance, while hiking in the woods, a group of friends lost their way. At night, they make a temporary shelter. In the morning, they see smoke in a particular direction.
The first premise is a directly observable “fact”, stating that the smoke is coming from that direction.
The second premise is the “reason” for the assertion. Since no other groups are hiking in the vicinity, the only plausible explanation is that their friends are the reason for the fire.
The third premise is an “example” they cite to prove the relationship between the first and second premise. Here, the connections must be authentic, including cause and effect, whole or part, substance and quality and class and individuals. The individuals in the group have seen their entire lives that fire causes smoke in the kitchen. Everyone knows that without fire, there would be no smoke.
The fourth premise is how they “apply” their inference to their benefit. Accordingly, the lost group comprehends that their friends set up the camp.
Thus, they “conclude” with the fifth premise that they must head in that direction.
Let us examine some relationships between ideas.
Whole and Part
A friend offers a water bottle to a thirsty one. She examines the material of the bottle and realizes it is stainless steel. She knows from school that it consists of iron (Fe), carbon (C), nickel (Ni) and chromium (Cr).
When our chemistry teacher asks what happens when hydrogen gas and oxygen gas combine, everybody knows the answer is water. We learn about the parts by studying the whole.
“Reductionism” is the analysis of an idea by reducing it into parts, and “holism” is comprehending it in its entirety by studying the functioning of the components.
Ayurveda is a holistic way of healing, whereas modern medicine is reductionist. A balance between these approaches may be appropriate.
The cells in the body do not operate like machine parts. They are constantly signalling each other. Thus, our body requires holistic healing and even behavioural changes if necessary. A reductionist view on recovery can fix a car because its components do not communicate. What happens to a tyre does not matter to a battery. Repairing a portion or replacing body parts will not permanently heal it as long as the cause remains.
A controlled lab environment in no way reflects the actual circumstances of any human. A rat does not conclude one day that it is obese and therefore decides to exercise back in shape, thus changing its physiology. Since we can change our bodies by actively engaging our minds, even torturing these poor creatures to understand ourselves is an outdated method of acquiring knowledge. Hence, customizing all treatments according to a patient’s prevailing situations is mandatory for a proper cure. A holistic medicine supplemented by a reductionist one is the way forward.
Substance and Quality
The water in the bottle is an idea that we call a substance to infer its qualities and purposes.
We know this tasteless and odourless molecule is a union of two hydrogen atoms and an oxygen atom through a covalent bond. It is an inorganic fluid vital for life, even though it has no nutritional value. We call this transparent liquid when it condenses as ice and evaporates as steam. Daily, we use it for many functions such as heating or cooling, cooking and washing.
We can also infer a substance from a function, like an idea that opens a door, which is a key.
Individuals and Classes
As part of a method to understand the world, we group ideas with similar characteristics.
To classify all living organisms through a hierarchy of groupings, scientists use binomial nomenclature for clarity, implying the genus and species. We are Homo sapiens; the coconut tree is Cocos nucifera; a lion is Panthera leo; wolves are Canis lupus. Animals with the same features constitute a grouping known as “taxa”. This classification also allows us to understand our evolution from single-cell organisms.
Seeing a tiger, a cyclist infers that its species name is tigris. The genus is Panthera, a cat with spots on its body, like lions, jaguars and leopards. It belongs to the family of Felidae or cats with claws, muscular bodies and flexible forelimbs. Furthermore, it is part of the order Carnivora, meaning it is a carnivorous animal with adjustable facial muscles for eating flesh. Instantly, they recognize it as a threat.
Dialectic Process
A “dialectic process” is acquiring knowledge through a dialogue between two or more people. Similar to the testimony of another person or a debate between different people. The purpose is to arrive at the truth and prevent misinformation by resolving differences.
Testimony
The lost group on the hike finally makes it to the camp and finds their friends. The guide informs them about a pack of wolves on the prowl. Without direct observation, they trust this information and never venture outside the camp.
A “testimony” is the knowledge that a person receives without direct observation. It has given us an edge over all other species and put us at the top of the food chain. When hunting, our ancestors conveyed all the relevant information to the group through a language.
We learn from our parents first. When we were children, our mother often advised us to check if vehicles were approaching from either side before crossing the road. Suppose one day, we rushed, ignoring her advice, and a rash driver almost killed us. In trauma, we would realize our mistakes and promise our mother never to disobey.
Advice is a form of testimony. It is like gooseberry juice that is bitter when we first taste it. Later, it turns out to be beneficial. We innately trust all the information our parents, teachers and elders share because they have the best intentions. They want us to prosper without committing the same mistakes that they did.
Testimony becomes relevant when one follows practical advice from any person or a guru. A particular path may lead to similar inner experiences in another person. Millions of people are benefiting from meditation.
Such internal experiences are incomprehensible to rats, mice and monkeys. Unlike these animals, we are a conscious life form. So, we should not outsource these validations to them.
Subjective experiences can differ from person to person. Our bodies may be of similar construct, but we function differently in the community due to our unique mind modifications. Every person can practise and validate the advice themselves. If they find meditation beneficial, let them do that. If they do not see it as helpful, they may avoid it and accept another or come up with one.
To be taken seriously, a testimony must fulfil two conditions. First, it must be the correct information, like the one on the pack of wolves. Secondly, it should impart communication without any mistakes. If the friend vaguely says wolves may be on the prowl, the lost group may take a risk and venture. Therefore, a testimony must clearly describe, discriminate and disseminate ideas.
Clear, precise language, free of ambiguity, is a prerequisite for knowing through testimony. An ideal language must follow an algorithmic and logical structure for easy learning.
Debate
A debate is a genuine attempt to resolve a doubt. We validate any simple hypothetical statement through a series of cross-questioning using legitimate means. For example, if the earth is round and not flat. The two people should not have preconceptions about each other when they set up their positions and refute their arguments.
One team presents a thesis that needs maintaining or proving, while the other side negates it by proposing an antithesis. When the intention is genuine, both teams may review or reject it by providing a valid explanation as the process evolves. At some point, a team wins or arrives at a synthesis together. They can maintain the current conditions if they cannot proceed further in their discussions.
In these dialectic processes, the changes advance spirally. If it goes around without moving, the debates become wranglings that do not go anywhere.
In a television debate, most discussions are wranglings, where the parties aim to win without interest in seeking knowledge. They refute each other when they realize their case is weak. Every so often, they cheat and deliberately pretend not to accept facts. Political opponents only want to win the argument, irrespective of where the truth lies. It is all about winning the election and setting a perspective for the voters.
All the politicians believe that emotions win elections, not rationality. Unfortunately, it is true because we let them charm us with their sweet talk and publicity stunts. It is an aspect of democracy that needs improvement. Hence, we must outsource the responsibility of revealing the truth to intellectuals.
We must strengthen the intellectual class to teach ordinary citizens to use their reason and vote. Even though they can have biases towards an ideology, they do not have to fool people to win elections. Therefore, we can consider their opinions trustworthy.
Let the debates have intellectuals with varying ideologies. We must leave it to the people to choose whatever makes sense to them.
An intellectual should become the torchbearer of truth in a democracy. We must never forget that democracy is imperfect, and its perfection is always a work in progress.
There are two methods to win debates: direct or indirect evidence.
An “indirect evidence” method gathers proof for the flat earth to substantiate otherwise. By noticing the absurdities, we prove that the world is round. For example, if we assume it is flat, every part must be either day or night. However, when the sunrise occurs on one part of the earth, it sets on the other. It indirectly proves the roundness of the world. A minor error in the evidence suggests the opposite is true.
To explain why the earth is round, we use the “direct evidence” method. An object becomes big as we approach it and smaller as we move away. However, our star is the same irrespective of its position in the sky. It happens when our position changes relative to the sun. Just rotate a flat mirror and see what happens. Our bodies appear to narrow away from the mirror. The earth’s round shape can only logically explain the stable size of the sun.
“Incomplete knowing” is where we have conflicting opinions on the validity of an experience.
“Doubt” arises when one cannot reflect on an idea with clarity. It creates a desire for investigation. A doubt takes a few minutes to several years of intense debate to settle. Light resolves if a man mistakes a rope for a snake. However, complex doubts about dark energy and dark matter may take years to resolve.
Analytical Process
“Analytical Process”: observe, collect and analyze information to conclude findings. Scientists brainstorm, detect patterns, theorize, validate and integrate conclusions. Efficiently investigating an issue can be a tedious process that requires precise methods.
Regardless, even ordinary people employ these processes to solve their concerns. A cycle store owner, analyzing the purchase bills, discovers an increase in the cost of the tyres from a particular supplier. On enquiry, the sales representative blames the rising rubber prices.
He studies the market demand, purchasing power, quality of the product and many more variables. Consequently, the owner reviews the future purchase order. If there is no satisfaction from the current supplier, he will buy more from another.
Scientific Analysis
An analysis is a logical approach to solving issues. An enquiry begins when attention falls to an idea. Using the remote control, we switch on the television. However, the television does not turn on. We wonder why and endeavour to solve the difficulty logically.
The first step is to make an “observation” that the remote control is not turning on the television.
The second step is to ask a “question”. Why is the remote control not turning on the television?
We propose a “hypothesis” in the third step—a plausible explanation to make sense of the problem. We will assume that the batteries in the remote control require replacement. This reason may not be accurate. Nevertheless, it must be testable and falsifiable. We must disregard it otherwise.
So, in the fourth step, we expect a result if our hypothesis is correct—a “prediction”. Let us predict that the remote control will function by changing the batteries.
We proceed to “test” the hypothesis in the fifth step. Assume we changed the batteries and checked.
Here there can be two possible results.
In result A, we find that the remote control is working, and the hypothesis is likely correct.
It is possibly wrong if the remote control is not working in result B. It is plausible that result B is due to faulty testing on account of dead batteries. We can verify this by making sure it is fresh.
There is always a chance our results could be wrong because there is not enough reliable data to back them up.
The last step is “iteration”. We analyze our results to make the next move. If our hypothesis is correct, we will examine the reason for the rapid depletion of new batteries. If it does not make sense, we develop a further explanation, like assuming a broken remote sensor and going back to the third step, proposing a new hypothesis.
Scientific analysis is a feedback loop where the results go back into the process until we determine all the answers. Later, our peers can evaluate all our findings.
Controlled Experiments
A hypothesis is an intelligent guess. However, it requires adequate tests to prove or disprove. Scientists keep all the factors constant except one or a few while testing. These experiments are tests that happen in a scientific lab.
Many hypotheses regarding the natural world may not be testable in a lab, like predicting the weather. So, scientists make predictions and compare results in nature and draw conclusions.
We want to find out if doing yoga for six weeks helps. So, after advertising in the newspaper and interviewing, we selected fifty people. We perform the necessary health checks and divide them into two groups with a sample size of twenty-five people: an “experimental group” and a “control group”.
The experimental group receives yoga training, while the control group does not. Here, there is only one variable while other factors, like food and leisure, stay constant. After six weeks and another health check later, we conclude that six weeks of yoga can improve the health of more than eighty per cent of people in this group. In contrast, there was no recognizable difference in the people’s health in the control group.
Scientists often resort to statistics to conclude correctly. The dependent variable is the effect of the independent one, which in our experiment is the intensity of yoga training on the people.
Of course, there can be variations in the results. Only sixty per cent of people may benefit if it is less intense, while an increase could work for everyone.
Such a small sample size is less likely to unravel the whole truth. Hence, multiple repetitions of experiments with a large sample size can be more accurate.
Mathematics
Mathematics is the language through which the cosmos talks to us. It assists us in understanding the world objectively and without bias, which is a prerequisite for advancing knowledge. It uses various tools to explore patterns and possibilities in reality by quantifying relationships. All discipline incorporates maths in some form to understand complex phenomena.
Every person needs a basic understanding of its applications to survive and prosper. The proof of its accuracy must exist in the observations in the physical world. In addition, its practicality must reflect in our daily lives. For example, the practical application of the Pythagorean theorem in real-life situations proves its validity. So, all mathematical equations must become testable in the natural world. We should not base deriving proofs on other mathematical equations.
However, mathematics must limit itself to measurable reality. It should not create a new magical world like the concept of parallel universes and many more. It is also subject to the test of validation. Hence, we must reject any mystical deductions that are not verifiable.
Unfortunately, people abuse it to prove their whims and fantasies. We see clouds in the form of a chicken if we are fond of it. Likewise, all subconsciously succumb to their personal bias in every matter. Those who believe the universe originated from a singularity will keep looking for equations that prove and reject everything that disapproves of it. Even if hypotheses look illogical or logical, with or without the backing of mathematical equations, do not accept them without testing them out in the natural world.
In addition, economists use it to rationalize irrational human behaviour. People have varying priorities. Hence, they think and act differently. We cannot constantly deduce a simple equation to study complex human behaviours.
A financial analyst may logically predict that a specific stock may go up. However, people may have illogical reasons to sell their shares. They may want money to pay for their daughter’s wedding, pay medical bills, finance a son’s education or set up a new business. There can be multiple reasons for people selling a good stock. Therefore, it is, unfortunately, idiotic to even think of predicting human behaviours through mathematical equations. We must strive to supplement our lives with maths, not enslave ourselves to it. Proper knowing is an essential skill for anyone seeking to grow as a person. It helps us live meaningfully and peacefully coexist with our fellow beings. In addition, it assists in solving problems and deciding our best interests. We can excel in all avenues of life by recognizing these processes and applying them in our lives.
We acquire knowledge through learning and experiences in life. People can use it positively to create or negatively to destroy. Undoubtedly, we must use it productively to progress ourselves and the community. It is a wasteful life if we do not use our wisdom for the world’s benefit.