The Philosophy of Everything — Part I: On Epistemology, Chapter 2: The Method of Observation
This chapter will teach us how we notice the world around us and how our minds decrypt all the experiences that we receive through our observations. Without realizing the constituents of reality, we will not reflect correctly on how it is built from the ground up.
The topics we cover here are:
- Observation
- Experience
- Ideas – The Description of an Idea, The Primary Types of Ideas
To observe, we employ our senses and other instruments. An “observation” is when we pay attention to an idea, no matter how rational or irrational it may be.
It can be “qualitative” if it has an attached quality, such as the ocean’s water being salty or a piece of paper being smooth.
When it varies in amount, it becomes “quantitative”. It could be a person’s height or how hot or cold it is where we are.
Measurement allows us to analyze and compare them with others at varying times and places. Using a standard unit, we equate two quantifiable observations. A kilogram is a unit that allows us to compare weights. Instruments such as microscopes, clocks and recorders aid our perceptions. Devices such as X-rays, infrared telescopes and ampere metres assist us in looking at inferential things.
Observing can sometimes alter the outcomes, like in the double-slit experiment in quantum mechanics. When we use a detector, the light acts like a particle instead of a wave. When filling our bicycle tyres, we cannot check the pressure without letting off some air. These disturbances are the “observer effects”.
All observations consist of experience and ideas.
Experience
When the alarm buzzes, the sound waves reach our ears. It enters the ear canal and causes the eardrum to vibrate. The eardrum transfers these vibrations to the malleus, incus and stapes, three tiny bones in the middle ear. These bones amplify and pass the vibrations to the inner ear, causing the fluid inside the cochlea to ripple. Like any ocean wave that falls on a beach, these ripples travel and collide with stereocilia, a microscopic hair-like projection. The tip opens, permitting chemicals to enter these cells and generate an electrical signal. The auditory nerve carries this signal to our brain, allowing us to recognize the alarm. It is the hearing process.
The brain receives all the information through the five basic senses: hearing, sight, smell, taste and touch. When it decrypts these signals, we have an “experience”.
Today, we use technology such as telescopes to magnify our senses and observe faraway planets that we would otherwise miss.
An experience may occur through one or more senses. We may simultaneously see, touch, smell and taste when eating. The brain imprints this information as a neurophysiological change. This impression of a particular experience is known as “engram”. Each sense induces a distinct neurophysiological change in the corresponding neural tissues of the brain. Hence, these imprints of an engram or memories reside in various brain sections. The neural cells collectively link these changes together to form a unit of experience. The permanency of an engram depends on how crucial it is for survival.
There are two kinds of experience: “primary” and “secondary”. The former occurs for the first time, such as when trying a portion of new food. Then, we have those secondary experiences from the primary’s association with the related ones in our memories.
The commercial for a burger might bring back memories of how it tasted on a prior occasion. We may sometimes experience a flood of memories of the same flavour. Such encounters give rise to two alternatives. It either enhances pleasure or induces pain. Accordingly, we may or may not consume the meal.
Nerves function similar to muscles. We may reinforce them by repeating information, which encourages the brain to attach importance to it. The more the data recurs, the more linkages strengthen and organize all the experiences. Learning anything new is challenging at first because new neural links develop gradually. We employ these tactics to memorize our textbooks even though they seem irrelevant to our basic survival. We deceive the brain into thinking otherwise.
Furthermore, we can condition our brains to establish or learn new habits through repetition. To overcome addictions, we merely need the will to stop using them. Like muscles, nerves also atrophy when not used for extended periods.
When we repeat the experiences often enough, they tend to become intuitive, like how, after a period, driving becomes effortless.
Ideas
Anything knowable is an “idea”. Intellect discriminates experiences into ideas to identify and avert any existential threat. We call them things such as “house”, “thoughts”, “mother”, “friend”, “trees” and “sun”.
An idea is constantly changing due to the transitory nature of our world. It forms, grows, decays, dies and recycles into new ones when the mind reflects on an experience. This cyclical process repeats perpetually.
However, there are a few exceptions where the ideas stay the same. They are the “universals”, such as whiteness, tallness, hotness and boldness.
“Relational” ideas establish relationships between two or more concepts, such as cooler, brighter, heavier and faster. We use them in conversation, mainly to make comparisons. For example, Rama is shorter than Mohan.
We can create a “story” through a set of ideas revolving around each other. A proper “language” facilitates logical and conclusive communication.
These are arbitrary concepts we use to make sense of our surroundings.
Each individual observes the same idea differently at various times. A person may infer that the sun orbits us by analyzing its changing position in the sky. It is a simple idea, but it takes a more profound analysis to picture our planet rotating on its axis. So, the experience can be deceptive if not put through proper study.
The observation of an idea is independent of the person. It means they continue to exist even if the observer is absent. Whether we observe it or not, our star will keep moving.
Experiences, both within and without, are a collection of ideas. Each concept comprises three components: physicality, functionality and specificity. Together, the three describe an idea that grows in complexity over time.
The Description of an Idea
Chuck Noland finds himself alone on an island after a plane crash. His gaze falls on a thick, tall wooden trunk on the beach, which he recognizes as a tree. On further inspection, the trunk develops from a swollen base and curves slightly at the top, where there is a crown of leaves. Instantly, he recollects it as a coconut tree from his botany lessons.
We first notice an idea’s physical characteristics, which constitute its “physicality”.
An investigation beyond physicality helps us realize how this idea functions or lies with another. It determines the “functionality” of an idea. From our perspective, these functions are the benefits we derive from them.
Chuck may benefit from a coconut tree in multiple ways. If thirsty, he hydrates by drinking coconut water. Consuming the white, fleshy layer of the coconut will quench his hunger. If he feels adventurous, he may build a canoe out of the trunk of the coconut tree. He could also use it to construct a hut to live in until his daring escape. The coconut leaves can serve as a roof shielding him from the rain. The husk makes way for a comfy mattress. The shells enable him to collect rainwater for drinking or produce music with them for entertainment.
“Specificity” is the feature that distinguishes similar ideas from each other. It requires in-depth analysis to understand them.
As days pass by, Chuck comes to understand the particularity of each coconut tree. He locates a particular coconut tree that meets his precise survival needs. Every coconut tree is distinct in height, yield, colouration and the taste of coconut water. In years to come, he will realize that some trees require extra mulching, while others are disease resistant and can withstand high winds and rain. He may have given each coconut tree a name and have had a favourite, Hooch.
In the case of humans or conscious animals, each individual can possess advancing levels of specificity.
We associate the idea of a tiger with any animal having a thick pelage with white ventral areas and prominent vertical black stripes. From our perspective, it is a predator capable of killing and, hence, a threat to our survival. Suddenly, when we come face-to-face, we recognize it and take the necessary steps to protect ourselves.
While cycling through a forest, we notice that the trees on either side are non-threatening and remain indifferent. If a branch is about to fall on us, it immediately becomes a threat. Likewise, we differentiate all our ideas primarily into those that are threatening and non-threatening.
The Primary Types of Ideas
Our brain categorizes all ideas into “threat” and “non-threat” categories because of our innate tendency to survive and reproduce.
A threat produces a painful experience, which our brain interprets as danger. If there is pain, the brain instantly initiates the process necessary to neutralize it. When a child touches anything hot, its brain senses pain and swiftly withdraws its hand to escape the threat.
Naina recalls from experience that hot coffee gives her pleasure. If the pain is within her limits, her mind will remind her that she enjoys hot coffee, making her want to bear it.
Let us assume a hypothetical scenario. When Naina was lethargic, her mother handed her a cup of hot coffee. As a result, she could focus and do well on the test. Her parents rewarded her hard work by giving her a new smartphone. Her brain now considers drinking hot coffee rewarding.
These memories will stay in her subconscious, while she may merely recall her fondness for hot coffee.
A sensory encounter that was formerly a threat, producing pain, is now a non-threat, inducing pleasure.
The brain is indifferent to non-threatening encounters unless they aid us in survival, which it detects through a pleasurable experience.
Non-threatening experiences are primarily of two types: “avoidable” and “acceptable”. We can either safely discard them or get some form of satisfaction that enhances our lives.
Every person uses this inherent mechanism of pleasure and pain to advance their lives and function in the world. All living things strive to avoid pain and accept pleasure.
Our brain does everything in its capacity to help us survive in the best possible way by adapting to a dynamic environment. It evaluates every experience for threats and discards those that are non-threat.
Suppose we pay attention to the colour of an approaching automobile while driving. In that case, the brain retains this information for a short period. When we recall such “short-term memories”, they become “long-term”. If any of these are not critical to our life, the brain rejects them at its discretion. What matters is that this particular automobile, regardless of what colour it is, passes safely. As a result, we will use our attention to avert a crash. Whenever we almost collide with another vehicle, we employ our expertise to prevent it.
People who work for the police or are witnesses to a crime may utilize their non-threatening experiences to assist in solving a case. They may provide clues during an investigation.
A banner on the Delhi-Mumbai expressway informs us that a fuel station is a few kilometres away. The fuel gauge indicates we will make it home comfortably. Now that the advertisement is a non-threat experience, it is safe to discard.
However, our minds can taunt us with a question. “What if there is an emergency, such as a fuel leak”? We might find ourselves in unfamiliar circumstances in the midst of nowhere. Our brain perceives such perplexing situations or uncertainties as threats.
Instead of rejecting a non-threat, we use it to reduce uncertainty and improve our chances of survival. We relieve ourselves if the fuel station has a restroom. We may get snacks from the store to ensure that we do not feel hungry for the remainder of the journey.
Finally, we arrived at our destination without any untoward incidents. There is no need to worry about overfilling the tank. A brief halt at the fuel station eliminated any future uncertainties. Thus, it avoids the possibility of pain and indirectly prevents any future risk to our chances of survival.
On his way home from work, a man observes a child crawling on a rooftop. As another life is in danger and not his, the instinct conveys the observation to the intellect for analysis. The intellect searches the memory for relevant or related facts; it contains information on a child falling from the roof and dying. It could be anything that conveys that the child’s life is at risk. Through this quick analysis, he concludes that the three-year-old is in danger. Now the intellect must identify the child. Thanks to his “self ”, he recognizes his child and rushes to its rescue.
This process of observing happens rapidly and is knowable through careful observation. If the man’s life were at stake, his instincts would involuntarily drive him to safety without delay.
A father’s instinctive reaction is to rush to his son’s aid. Even if it means risking his life, he will protect his child because, innately, he is protecting the continuation of his genes. Evolution favoured this type of behaviour, and every parent does this subconsciously. We call this an act of love to make an animal’s nature appear meaningful and humane.
A ball rather than a child will elicit indifference in the man. If it is somebody else’s child, his conscience determines the response after a personal threat analysis. If there is a danger to his life, he will refuse to save it.
Each individual responds to comparable situations in a myriad of ways. Hence, we cannot generalize any responses when it comes to people. Our unique mental modification produces many exceptions in all these circumstances.
Deer take pleasure in the grass. It innately knows how vital it is for its survival. When the same deer sees a tiger, it flees for its life.
Assume our ancestor sees the same tiger, but instead of perceiving it as a threat, he views it as an opportunity to demonstrate his bravery. By hunting it, he hopes to project himself as a prospective leader of the tribe.
The deer disregards the moon as a non-threat. At the same time, the hunter’s wife describes the moon in a poem and eagerly awaits the chance to recite it. The moon is an avoidable non-threat that she consciously transforms into a pleasing experience to derive pleasure and meaning.
Sometimes, humans are capable of swapping non-threats for threats and back and forth. A man out for a jog comes upon a snake minding its business. His instincts will ask him to discard it. However, he feels concerned that someone may inadvertently tread on the snake. It may be his wife, who is running a few minutes late. So, the man is now weighing his options. His first choice is to slay the snake. Since he has concerns for other life forms, he uses a stick to shove the snake far into the woods. From the animal’s perspective, something is endangering its life. So, the snake hisses many times to leave it alone. Despite the warning, he knows what is best for the snake and everyone else. Hence, he continues to push it away from the thoroughfare. The snake bites and moves out. His wife whisks him away to the hospital. Instead of discarding a non-threat, he turns it into a threat to his life. In the past, evolution did not favour the veracity of our knowledge. The only requirement was that anything we know, think or believe should not pose any risk to our survival. In modern technological culture, invalid ideas are stoking differences and violence. They are now threatening and diminishing our chances of survival. Thus, acquiring the right way to know is necessary to prevent our intellect from hindering our progress.