NP Nithin Palal

Chapter 1: Truth

Part I: On Epistemology

· 6 min read · Discuss · Plain text

The Philosophy of Everything — Part I: On Epistemology, Chapter 1: Truth

This chapter explains the essence of truth and the significance of validating a belief. Most of the world’s issues trace back to the inability to understand knowledge. So, it is crucial to grasp the concept of truth to solve the problems between “our” God and “their” God. This clarity will enable us to distinguish the truth from untruths. Knowing it is the first step towards freedom because it delinks the direction of truth from the path that leads to it.

The topics we cover here are:

  • Absolute Truth
  • Subjective and Objective Truth
  • Changing and Unchanging Truth
  • Determinate and Indeterminate Truth

The knowledge that nobody can falsify is the “absolute truth”. There can be subjective and objective truth, depending on the number of observers.

“Subjective truth” is when the truth matter only to a single observer, like a man who knows a woman is no longer in love with him.

In a court, the judge settles a murder case by analyzing the testimony of many witnesses to arrive at an “objective truth”. Regardless of their failing memory, the truth will always exist.

Let us suppose that the witnesses are genuine. This truth is a reality of a past event and is changeless. In contrast, the changing truth is when the woman falls in love again with the man. Whether changing or unchanging, it eradicates all separation arising from our divergent upbringing. It has the power to resolve the dispute between our God and their God.

In life, the truth manifests itself in a variety of ways. However, generally speaking, it can be either determinable or indeterminable.

On hearing the alarm, we make the following arguments:

Fact: The alarm is ringing.

Reason: The music we hear corresponds to our alarm.

Example: Whenever we hear this music in the morning, we know it is

the alarm.

Application: It must be 6 a.m. since we set the alarm at that time.

Conclusion: Therefore, it is time to wake up.

This example is a form of syllogistic reasoning. It is a process by which we examine the relationship between numerous observations. These arguments conclude in a “determinate truth”.

Several approaches to determining the truth are available. Scientists using mathematical equations in their studies is one of them. There is always the potential that a new argument may refute or clarify it. It becomes invalid if the alarm features music that sounds like a phone call and is one.

Scientists often update such changing truths. Consider what would happen if the scientific community rejected Einstein to placate a Newtonian. We would never have a GPS to track our workouts. Therefore, discovering the truth should always be a journey rather than a destination.

“Indeterminate truths” transcend our perception and inference. We cannot determine them at the moment.

The observations without proper validation that a layperson uses to deduce the world are “beliefs”. It can be either true or false. We know the sun lights the day because there would be no light without the sun. On the other hand, if someone thinks the moon lights up the night, they are wrong because it only reflects sunlight.

There was a time when people could not understand what lightning and thunder meant. The brain considers uncertainty a potential threat and compels us to come up with an explanation. We make sense of all phenomena beyond our understanding by attributing them to a mystical entity in the past. So, our ancestors mistook it for divine vengeance. Accordingly, their happiness always depends on appeasing an external entity. Even though such beliefs cause violence and mass killings, they did not imperil our existence in the past.

In a hypothetical scenario, someone informs us that an asteroid, 99942 Apophis, will end the world on April 13, 2036. People who have similar beliefs quickly establish congregations. They refer to scriptures and justify their beliefs, calling it a prophecy and thus launching a new “faith”. Donations pour in, and the founder purchases a ranch to house its global headquarters. If an optimist with a credible following disagrees with the founder, considering it merely a warning sign from God and not the end of the world, the faith splits. However, the saga continues.

According to preliminary orbital calculations, this asteroid may pass through our gravitational keyhole in 2029. Scientists know that when an object enters this little zone, gravity may modify its path and force it to crash on its following approach. This date happens to be April 13, 2036. Additional orbital simulations say such an event will not likely occur in another century.

At the end of the Jurassic Era, a 10 k.m. wide and 20 k.m. long asteroid did not destroy the world. An asteroid 370 metres wide is not ending the world. We can now either deflect or destroy an asteroid. If there is a threat to our existence, all humans will work together to avoid calamity.

Culture has a significant impact on the process of believing. We pick up right and wrong beliefs from our parents at a tender age. Children believe that Santa Claus will bring them presents at Christmas. Such stories are absolute truths for many children.

We need not correct them because children will not understand profound truths. They learn incredibly complex lessons through engaging stories and entertaining narratives. To understand virtue, they require cartoons and movies.

Unfortunately, there are several tales that we refuse to let go of after getting older. Growing up, we must wean off such notions and return to a rational life. People should not become susceptible to vague understandings by merely focusing on what makes sense.

People assume that movies portray factual history. The creators introduce numerous untruths to make it dramatic. Every artist must have a creative licence, but they forget that a tiny deviation from the truth becomes authentic with time. Unfortunately, actual history is boring without romance, humour, action, crimes and thrills.

Misinforming through an artistic depiction of an actual event has the potential to alter the truth. Although 2.5 million Indians volunteered to serve in World War II, there is no representation of a single Indian soldier in the 2017 film Dunkirk.

The movie may be a work of fiction, but the people may forget the sacrifices of the commonwealth soldiers. People must understand that these are a means of entertainment and not education. They need to learn to enjoy non-fiction books and documentaries in their youth.

Stories, on the other hand, feed our imaginations. It may cause a societal change and alter our future for the better or worse.

Harriet Beecher Stowe’s book Uncle Tom’s Cabin, published in 1852, had a profound impact on nineteenth-century American culture. Historians believe that this work of fiction was one of the causes of the four-year American Civil War (1861–65). It relates to the miseries of an enslaved black man and the individuals surrounding him. Through him, people started to comprehend the plight of blacks and the realities of slavery. This novel is responsible for a significant shift in most whites’ attitudes regarding African Americans.

Such artworks shed light on real-life circumstances and have the potential to influence society. It can lead to momentous occasions that have far-reaching consequences for our civilization.

The conditioning of our minds through indoctrination produces several beliefs that, unfortunately, circulate in our society as theories. It is now causing a slew of problems. Today, everyone has access to a wealth of information. We must, therefore, critically evaluate each one, much like a doctor assessing symptoms before prescribing medication. Then, we have to decondition ourselves from invalid beliefs.

We must distinguish the wheat from the chaff, especially in this age of fake news. We are truth-seekers innately because of our urge to remove uncertainty, and we should remain as such. The COVID-19 pandemic taught us a valuable lesson: if people do not work together, even a virus may wreak havoc on our lives. Since the moment has come for conscious living, let us take charge of our lives by realizing the truth.

Indeterminate truths may or may not become determinate as science advances. Until then, we must be mindful of our convictions and keep our beliefs in check.

The mental modifications cause different observations, similar to how we define the fragrance of our perfume. The explanations of each individual differ merely in their proximity to the truth. Hence, no one should impose their beliefs on others, as individual observations vary due to differing intelligence. It is preferable to let people discover their way to the truth.

Before we can determine what is true, we should know how we observe.

↑ Back to top

Discuss

Loading the discussion…

More in Philosophy
  •  ·  12 min read
    Philosophy · Unlearning

    Conclusion

    ← Previous: Chapter 16: A Meaningful Life · Series hub There is no one above to blame for your life, and no one up there coming to fix it. That is not the bad news. It is the moment your life finally becomes your own. In brief: In this conclusion I stand back with you, at the top of the last hill, and look down the whole road once. I gather what the series has tried to say about truth, about what is real, about the mind and about living with other people. Then I set down the one thing all the...

  •  ·  33 min read
    Philosophy · Unlearning

    Chapter 16: A Meaningful Life

    ← Previous: Chapter 15: Organisation of Society · Series hub · Next: Conclusion → You can have the rent paid, the door locked and the people you love asleep down the hall, and still find no reason to get up. Meaning is not a thing you find but a circle you keep widening. In brief: In this last chapter I take up the grey morning when nothing is wrong and nothing is enough. I give the missing thing its plain name, meaning, and I show you where I found it. It is not in more comfort, and it is...

  •  ·  25 min read
    Philosophy · Unlearning

    Chapter 15: Organisation of Society

    ← Previous: Chapter 14: Peaceful Coexistence · Series hub · Next: Chapter 16: A Meaningful Life → The most dangerous criminal in your country is not the one we chase down the alley. He wears a clean shirt, holds high office, and steals the school your child never got to sit in. In brief: In this chapter I take on the question I put off the longest. It is how to make the line between people hold for millions of strangers who will never feel any warmth for one another. My answer is a shelter...