Index
Lines to keep
97 lines from 9 articles
Some articles end with a sentence instead of a term. These are those sentences, each with the piece it comes from.
Sanatan Dharma · 63
“The hymn a whole theatre sang begins with an admission: I lack understanding. Give me a better mind.” The Chalisa opens with humility and asks for strength, intelligence and knowledge. Here devotion does not replace thinking; it prays for better thinking. One prayer does not prove that every devotional practice encourages inquiry, but this one does.
Why Devotion Needs Logic, and Logic Needs Devotion — What Hanuman Ansh Taught Me on the Way Home“Devotion supplies neither truth nor goodness by itself. Reason supplies neither purpose nor virtue by itself.” The two are not rivals. Each disciplines the other, and neither can certify itself.
Why Devotion Needs Logic, and Logic Needs Devotion — What Hanuman Ansh Taught Me on the Way Home“Ask of any belief you hold dear: what would make me doubt it? If nothing could, the belief is sealed.” The test applies to gurus, ideologies, scientific assumptions and our own loyalties. A firm belief is not a sealed one; a belief that no evidence could touch is.
Why Devotion Needs Logic, and Logic Needs Devotion — What Hanuman Ansh Taught Me on the Way Home“Both the believer’s authorities and the reasoner’s tools can be captured.” Scripture and teachers can be used to block scrutiny. So can logic, data and expertise used selectively. Not every source is equally reliable; each must be weighed for what it actually is.
Why Devotion Needs Logic, and Logic Needs Devotion — What Hanuman Ansh Taught Me on the Way Home“Explaining why I feel something is one task. Deciding what to do about it is another.” Understanding an emotion can improve a decision. It cannot make the decision.
Why Devotion Needs Logic, and Logic Needs Devotion — What Hanuman Ansh Taught Me on the Way Home“Meaning is not good just because it is meaningful.” Destructive ideologies give people purpose too. The strength of a commitment says nothing about its goodness.
Why Devotion Needs Logic, and Logic Needs Devotion — What Hanuman Ansh Taught Me on the Way Home“An experience can be real without every explanation of it being true.” Report, explanation, effect and obligation are four different claims. Honour the first without assuming the rest.
Why Devotion Needs Logic, and Logic Needs Devotion — What Hanuman Ansh Taught Me on the Way Home“Every claim answers to the test that fits it. Nothing gets a permanent exemption.” This rejects both the demand that every experience become a lab result and the demand that religious claims be beyond checking.
Why Devotion Needs Logic, and Logic Needs Devotion — What Hanuman Ansh Taught Me on the Way Home“Inheritance is not exemption from scrutiny.” A tradition can give us languages, stories and practices without making every inherited claim immune to examination. Preserving and examining are not opposites.
Why Devotion Needs Logic, and Logic Needs Devotion — What Hanuman Ansh Taught Me on the Way Home“Devotion must never be used to make the suffering of the wronged look holy.” An interpretation of suffering must be judged by what it asks the vulnerable to endure, and whom it protects.
Why Devotion Needs Logic, and Logic Needs Devotion — What Hanuman Ansh Taught Me on the Way Home“A tradition that cannot expose its frauds cannot protect its saints.” Accountability is not hostility to a tradition; it is how a tradition keeps its credibility. It also needs fair process, because an accusation is not proof.
Why Devotion Needs Logic, and Logic Needs Devotion — What Hanuman Ansh Taught Me on the Way Home“Devotion and rigorous science can live in the same person.” One life holding both does not validate every religious or scientific claim. It shows that the war between them is not a law of nature.
Why Devotion Needs Logic, and Logic Needs Devotion — What Hanuman Ansh Taught Me on the Way Home“Stay corrigible, not gullible.” Openness to correction means revising in proportion to evidence, not changing your mind for whoever speaks loudest.
Why Devotion Needs Logic, and Logic Needs Devotion — What Hanuman Ansh Taught Me on the Way Home“Keep the faith. Keep the questions.” Commitment need not mean surrender, and questioning need not mean contempt. Sometimes a cherished belief must still be revised; the phrase invites disciplined inquiry, not a promise that every belief survives it.
Why Devotion Needs Logic, and Logic Needs Devotion — What Hanuman Ansh Taught Me on the Way HomeBuddhimatāṃ variṣṭham: “foremost among the intelligent”, Hanuman’s epithet in the Rāma Rakṣā Stotra.
Why Devotion Needs Logic, and Logic Needs Devotion — What Hanuman Ansh Taught Me on the Way HomeBala, buddhi, vidyā: strength, intelligence and knowledge, what the Chalisa asks Hanuman for.
Why Devotion Needs Logic, and Logic Needs Devotion — What Hanuman Ansh Taught Me on the Way HomeSvasvarūpānusandhāna: inquiry into one’s own true nature, which the Vivekacūḍāmaṇi calls devotion. An Advaita definition, not every school’s.
Why Devotion Needs Logic, and Logic Needs Devotion — What Hanuman Ansh Taught Me on the Way HomeCorrigibility: the capacity to recognise when a belief needs revising, and to revise it for good reasons. Not the same as doubt.
Why Devotion Needs Logic, and Logic Needs Devotion — What Hanuman Ansh Taught Me on the Way HomeDimāgī Sanātanī: my name for a person rooted in a tradition who keeps every inherited belief open to examination.
Why Devotion Needs Logic, and Logic Needs Devotion — What Hanuman Ansh Taught Me on the Way Home“A verdict on craft is not a verdict on the whole.” A film can be badly paced and still move people, or beautifully made and ethically troubling. One score cannot carry every judgement.
What the Critics Got Right and Wrong About Hanuman Ansh — A Philosophical Review of the Reviews“The box office can refute a forecast. It cannot refute a judgement of craft.” Predictions can be checked against outcomes; quality cannot be settled by ticket sales, in either direction.
What the Critics Got Right and Wrong About Hanuman Ansh — A Philosophical Review of the Reviews“A critic with a polished mirror and a closed heart sees every flaw and misses what the work does. A devotee with an open heart and an unpolished mirror feels everything and judges nothing.” Neither training nor feeling is enough alone. This is an ideal to aim at, not a label for people who disagree with you.
What the Critics Got Right and Wrong About Hanuman Ansh — A Philosophical Review of the Reviews“The film slides from bhakti into adbhuta: from devotion into amazement at the devotee.” My reading of the second half. Wonder is not the problem; wonder that adds nothing new, and turns attention from service to power, is.
What the Critics Got Right and Wrong About Hanuman Ansh — A Philosophical Review of the Reviews“A bhajan that repeats is doing its job. A film that repeats the same kind of scene may not be.” Judge repetition by what it does: deepen, or merely pile up.
What the Critics Got Right and Wrong About Hanuman Ansh — A Philosophical Review of the Reviews“The saint’s following alone cannot explain the difference.” Two films on the same saint fared very differently. That rules out one simple explanation; it does not prove another.
What the Critics Got Right and Wrong About Hanuman Ansh — A Philosophical Review of the Reviews“Grief is a door most of us have walked through.” The film opens with loss, which reaches people who do not share its theology. A shared emotion does not guarantee a shared interpretation.
What the Critics Got Right and Wrong About Hanuman Ansh — A Philosophical Review of the Reviews“Comfort is not a substitute for a different kind of help.” A film can console. It cannot replace care that someone needs.
What the Critics Got Right and Wrong About Hanuman Ansh — A Philosophical Review of the Reviews“A critic’s error costs a film a few stars. A devotee’s refusal to hear criticism costs a tradition its ability to correct itself.” Disagreeing with a critic is fine. Treating disagreement as disloyalty is what does the damage.
What the Critics Got Right and Wrong About Hanuman Ansh — A Philosophical Review of the Reviews“Reflect on it fully, then do as you wish.” (Gītā 18.63) Even Kṛṣṇa leaves Arjuna room to think. I use the verse against the idea that devotion requires suspending judgement.
What the Critics Got Right and Wrong About Hanuman Ansh — A Philosophical Review of the ReviewsSahṛdaya: the cultivated, responsive viewer: trained in form, open in heart.
What the Critics Got Right and Wrong About Hanuman Ansh — A Philosophical Review of the ReviewsAnekāntavāda: the Jain teaching that reality has many sides. A reason to check the scope of a claim, not to treat every claim as equal.
What the Critics Got Right and Wrong About Hanuman Ansh — A Philosophical Review of the ReviewsKaruṇa, adbhuta, śānta rasa: the aesthetic tastes of grief, wonder and peace.
What the Critics Got Right and Wrong About Hanuman Ansh — A Philosophical Review of the ReviewsBhakti rasa: devotional rasa, as developed by Rūpa Gosvāmī in the Vaiṣṇava tradition. Not one of Bharata’s original eight.
What the Critics Got Right and Wrong About Hanuman Ansh — A Philosophical Review of the ReviewsDharma: used here as a practical question about what values a film commends and what conduct it encourages, not as a full definition.
What the Critics Got Right and Wrong About Hanuman Ansh — A Philosophical Review of the Reviews“A miracle story can be a lesson with a memory lock fitted to it.” An impossible detail makes a story stick; the lesson is what it carries. This describes how some stories work, not all. Some locks also guard a teacher’s authority or a community’s identity, so ask who benefits from the telling.
The Miracles of Hanuman Ansh Explained with Logic — What Each Story Really Teaches“Finding a lesson does not prove the event happened. Failing to prove the event does not destroy the lesson.” History and meaning are different kinds of claim. Keep them apart, and neither can be used to smuggle in the other.
The Miracles of Hanuman Ansh Explained with Logic — What Each Story Really Teaches“Testimony is the statement of a reliable person.” (Nyāya Sūtra 1.1.7) Sincerity is not enough. Ask whether the witness saw it, could tell it accurately, and is independent of other tellers.
The Miracles of Hanuman Ansh Explained with Logic — What Each Story Really Teaches“Not knowing a cause is not evidence for a supernatural one.” An unexplained event is not automatically a miracle, and a story called a miracle is not automatically an established event.
The Miracles of Hanuman Ansh Explained with Logic — What Each Story Really Teaches“To defend Sanātana, you do not need to defend every miracle.” Some of its most influential disciplines treated extraordinary powers as a detour. This is my argument, not a claim that every tradition agrees.
The Miracles of Hanuman Ansh Explained with Logic — What Each Story Really Teaches“The story asks for a station.” Read as a story about leverage, the train asks what you demand when you suddenly hold power. The station is not proof of the miracle; it is the image the question hangs on.
The Miracles of Hanuman Ansh Explained with Logic — What Each Story Really Teaches“The ideal for a person is to act like the saint. The ideal for a society is to need fewer saints.” Justice should not depend on exceptional people. If a village needs a halt, there should be an ordinary way to get one.
The Miracles of Hanuman Ansh Explained with Logic — What Each Story Really Teaches“Make food plentiful; that is the vow.” (Taittirīya Upaniṣad 3.9) Read beside the Upaniṣad, the ghee story turns abundance into a duty. The question is not whether you can work a miracle but whether your community feeds people.
The Miracles of Hanuman Ansh Explained with Logic — What Each Story Really Teaches“Care can open a conversation that argument alone could not.” Being fed can lower defences and build trust. It does not make a belief true; it changes whether people will listen.
The Miracles of Hanuman Ansh Explained with Logic — What Each Story Really Teaches“A reversal is not the same as reform.” One act of kindness across a boundary exposes an injustice. Only changed rules end it.
The Miracles of Hanuman Ansh Explained with Logic — What Each Story Really Teaches“A prediction sold with a guarantee deserves suspicion before it deserves your money.” Was it written down first, specific, unlikely, and checked by someone independent? If not, it is a story.
The Miracles of Hanuman Ansh Explained with Logic — What Each Story Really Teaches“A teaching that offers only inner freedom, and forgets the outer, has made its peace with injustice.” Inner and outer freedom are tangled. Neither can stand in for the other.
The Miracles of Hanuman Ansh Explained with Logic — What Each Story Really TeachesPramāṇa: a valid means of knowing. Nyāya accepts four: perception, inference, comparison and testimony. Other schools accept different lists.
The Miracles of Hanuman Ansh Explained with Logic — What Each Story Really TeachesĀpta: a reliable witness, one with knowledge, honest intent and the ability to tell it well.
The Miracles of Hanuman Ansh Explained with Logic — What Each Story Really TeachesSiddhi: an extraordinary power. The Yoga Sūtra calls such powers obstacles to samādhi.
The Miracles of Hanuman Ansh Explained with Logic — What Each Story Really TeachesVyavahāra and paramārtha: in Advaita, the practical and the ultimate standpoints. Used here only as an analogy.
The Miracles of Hanuman Ansh Explained with Logic — What Each Story Really TeachesMokṣa: liberation, understood differently across schools. My working definition is my own.
The Miracles of Hanuman Ansh Explained with Logic — What Each Story Really Teaches“The multiplex did not have to become holy. The people carried the temple in with them.” A place does not need to be consecrated for people to bring reverence into it. The line moves attention from the building to the conduct and attention of the people inside. It is my interpretation, not a claim that every viewer experienced the hall the same way.
Why People Took Off Their Shoes to Watch Hanuman Ansh — When a Multiplex Became a Temple“Explaining how a feeling happens is not the same as proving it is worthless.” Psychology can explain how music, grief and crowds produce emotion. Knowing the mechanism does not make the emotion fake.
Why People Took Off Their Shoes to Watch Hanuman Ansh — When a Multiplex Became a Temple“Feeling something deeply is not the same as proving it is true.” The intensity of an experience is a fact about the experience, not evidence for every belief attached to it. You can honour the experience without accepting all its claims.
Why People Took Off Their Shoes to Watch Hanuman Ansh — When a Multiplex Became a Temple“Freedom is not the absence of influence. It is the ability to notice your influences, weigh them, and choose.” Nobody chooses in a vacuum. Freedom asks for awareness, not escape. Sometimes the practical objection, a mother’s “the floor is dirty”, is the one worth keeping.
Why People Took Off Their Shoes to Watch Hanuman Ansh — When a Multiplex Became a Temple“The freedom to show reverence and the freedom to decline it must be protected together.” A devotional act means most when refusing it remains possible. Keeping your shoes on should never cost you respect.
Why People Took Off Their Shoes to Watch Hanuman Ansh — When a Multiplex Became a Temple“Reverence done and reverence displayed are not the same thing.” The same gesture can express commitment or seek approval, and a camera cannot tell which. This is not an accusation against anyone; it is a reminder that visibility is not depth.
Why People Took Off Their Shoes to Watch Hanuman Ansh — When a Multiplex Became a Temple“Popularity proves a need, not a truth.” Box office shows that a film answered a hunger. It cannot show that its miracles happened, that every viewer felt the same, or that the film is good art.
Why People Took Off Their Shoes to Watch Hanuman Ansh — When a Multiplex Became a Temple“A civilisation that can still gather attention that is not wholly for sale is not finished.” People can meet something inside a paid experience that the ticket does not measure. The warning: the same attention can later be packaged and sold. Ask what gathered the crowd, who profits, and whether people remain free to think.
Why People Took Off Their Shoes to Watch Hanuman Ansh — When a Multiplex Became a Temple“A person is made of faith. As his faith is, so is he.” (Gītā 17.3) The question is not only whether you have faith, but what you place it in and whether it stays open to examination. That modern use is my reading of the verse.
Why People Took Off Their Shoes to Watch Hanuman Ansh — When a Multiplex Became a TempleDarśana: seeing the divine and being seen by it. I extend it, as an interpretation, to a cinema screen.
Why People Took Off Their Shoes to Watch Hanuman Ansh — When a Multiplex Became a TempleAṃśa: a part or portion. Devotees regard Neem Karoli Baba as an aṃśa of Hanuman; that is a belief, not a historical finding.
Why People Took Off Their Shoes to Watch Hanuman Ansh — When a Multiplex Became a TempleRasa: the aesthetic tasting of an emotion shaped by a work of art. Karuṇa is the taste of grief and compassion; śānta the taste of peace, whose status as a rasa was long debated.
Why People Took Off Their Shoes to Watch Hanuman Ansh — When a Multiplex Became a Temple
Satyameva Jayate · 26
The rupee reaches her. Whether the reservation does is the question.
One Rupee, Two Ledgers — Why a Third of Karnataka's SC and ST Fund Is Booked to the GuaranteesOne scheme, two labels.
One Rupee, Two Ledgers — Why a Third of Karnataka's SC and ST Fund Is Booked to the GuaranteesA canal needed no beneficiary.
One Rupee, Two Ledgers — Why a Third of Karnataka's SC and ST Fund Is Booked to the GuaranteesEqual treatment was delivered. Special care was booked.
One Rupee, Two Ledgers — Why a Third of Karnataka's SC and ST Fund Is Booked to the GuaranteesAn earmark protects a group only when it pays for something that would not have been bought without it.
One Rupee, Two Ledgers — Why a Third of Karnataka's SC and ST Fund Is Booked to the GuaranteesEqual sums neither prove nor disprove that a gap was narrowed.
One Rupee, Two Ledgers — Why a Third of Karnataka's SC and ST Fund Is Booked to the GuaranteesThe same rule gives both results.
One Rupee, Two Ledgers — Why a Third of Karnataka's SC and ST Fund Is Booked to the GuaranteesGrain does not become land.
One Rupee, Two Ledgers — Why a Third of Karnataka's SC and ST Fund Is Booked to the GuaranteesKarnataka is just inside two of its three legal limits and outside the third.
The Note That Said No — Can Karnataka Afford What It Promised?A bill counts as spending when it is paid, not when the work is done.
The Note That Said No — Can Karnataka Afford What It Promised?Interest now costs the state more than the five guarantees.
The Note That Said No — Can Karnataka Afford What It Promised?In rupees, the debt grew by almost the same amount in the last two BJP years as in the first two Congress years.
The Note That Said No — Can Karnataka Afford What It Promised?Each government names the constraint it was handed and is silent on the commitment it added.
The Note That Said No — Can Karnataka Afford What It Promised?The state got less than it would have under the old formula, not less than before.
The Note That Said No — Can Karnataka Afford What It Promised?The queue for the state's money follows power.
The Note That Said No — Can Karnataka Afford What It Promised?Every way out moves the wait to someone.
The Note That Said No — Can Karnataka Afford What It Promised?Not one of the reports I read on the unpaid bills mentions a labourer.
The Note That Said No — Can Karnataka Afford What It Promised?When the next rupee falls short, who is told to wait, and where is that decision written down?
The Note That Said No — Can Karnataka Afford What It Promised?Karnataka delivered five guarantees at a scale few states have tried, and then argued in court that the women it pays cannot claim the money as a right.
Two Months Missing — Did Karnataka's Five Guarantees Reach the People They Named?A government that pays 36 instalments in 39 months has kept its word 36 times. It has also left months unpaid.
Two Months Missing — Did Karnataka's Five Guarantees Reach the People They Named?Do not ask what was announced. Ask what was credited, to whom, and on what date.
Two Months Missing — Did Karnataka's Five Guarantees Reach the People They Named?A transfer that is predictable is worth more than the same rupees paid at random.
Two Months Missing — Did Karnataka's Five Guarantees Reach the People They Named?The delivery is proven. The benefit is reported by those who receive it. The size of the change is not yet measured.
Two Months Missing — Did Karnataka's Five Guarantees Reach the People They Named?When cash is short, the payment a citizen cannot enforce is the one that waits.
Two Months Missing — Did Karnataka's Five Guarantees Reach the People They Named?A date, a duty, a ledger, a denominator and a desk: with those five, the word "guarantee" would describe the scheme as well as advertise it.
Two Months Missing — Did Karnataka's Five Guarantees Reach the People They Named?A political promise, a government scheme and an enforceable right are three different things.
Two Months Missing — Did Karnataka's Five Guarantees Reach the People They Named?
Viksit Bharat · 1
Cārvāka or Lokāyata: the Indian materialists, who denied the authority of the Vedas and life after death.
A Trophy, a Museum or a Weapon? — Why India should read its ancient wisdom like a laboratory notebook, not obey it like a command
Opinions · 7
“Two cheats do not make an honest scale.” A bias in our favour does not cancel a bias against us. It adds a second one.
Zero the Scale“Nobody put it there out of malice. Everybody simply read it as zero.” The skew is mostly habit, not conspiracy. That is why it is hard to see.
Zero the Scale“No one stole our pages. We left them offline.” Part of the gap is our own doing, so part of the fix is ours.
Zero the Scale“Priority is the claim, and priority is enough.” Mādhava came first. Saying Europe copied him needs evidence we do not yet have.
Zero the Scale“Neutral ground is not a spot halfway between Harvard and Kāśī. It is a rule that binds both.” Neutrality is a shared procedure, not a compromise position.
Zero the Scale“A benchmark that rewards the confident answer over the true one trains a machine for jalpa.” Whoever writes the test decides what a machine learns to value.
Zero the Scale“It costs us a story. It buys us a hearing for Mādhava.” Testing our weak claims is what earns our strong claims a hearing.
Zero the Scale