To judge the film on the screen, as he has for eleven years.
Needs
To say what his verdict measures and what it cannot see.
Stands to lose
His authority as a critic, once a film he dismissed fills halls for weeks.
Strength
He holds to his judgement and is honest about its limits.
Flaw
He takes the screen for the whole event.
The question their story asksCan a critic be right about a film and still miss what happened in the room?
Witness. He is sent to observe the phenomenon and reports what his own tools could not register.
The arc
FromA critic whose two stars are the whole story.
→
ToA critic who keeps the two stars and says what they measured.
He does not recant. He watches the room where he had watched the screen, and writes that stars measure the screen. Readers argue with him from both sides, and he takes that as a sign he got it about right.
part of the arc is hidden until you have read What the Critics Got Right and Wrong About Hanuman Ansh — A Philosophical Review of the Reviews.
In the film's fifth week his editor sends him to Lucknow. At the back of Audi 3 he watches the room. Nobody leaves during the credits. On the train home he types a title he cannot yet justify.
I Reviewed the Screen. I Should Have Reviewed the Room.
He did not need to change his verdict. He needed to say what it measured.
later lines are hidden.
People
Sunil Yadavfloor manager of the multiplex he visits
Rohan stands in the hall where Sunil has laid out the plastic sheet for footwear.
What they carry
The author invents him to stand for a kind of critic, and for the third of the series' capacities: how we take criticism. A judgement can be sound and still partial. Craft and what a room does with a film are separate measures.