NP Nithin Palal

Karthik

A business-school graduate who brings the machines to his uncle's mill.

Anything later stays hidden. The site also remembers the chapters you open on this device.
File AIPR-006Major · Herald
Role
Rajan's nephew, twenty-six, just out of IIM Bangalore
Also called
Rajan's nephew
Age
Twenty-six.
Work
Has just finished business school at IIM Bangalore.
Home
Singapore
Family
Nephew of Rajan Subramanian.
Looks
Arrives with 'the bright face of a young man who believes he is about to change someone's mind'.
Habits
Phones his uncle every Sunday. Thorough, and kind about it.
First seen
Part I
Appears in
9 of 54 pieces, and is spoken of in 2 more

What drives them

Wants

To change his uncle's mind about the software.

Needs

To see that the systems he trusts have blind spots and interests of their own, his included, and to put his own interest in writing.

Stands to lose

His uncle's trust and, later, his standing at his firm, where part of his enthusiasm is a nephew's.

Strength

Patient, thorough and truthful. He asks the one question that lands, and he does not press the point when the records prove him right.

Flaw

He advises everything at once, and takes a platform for the end of middlemen.

The question their story asksCan the nephew who believes in the system make his uncle examine himself without losing him?

Herald. He carries the machine into Rajan's office and keeps bringing the question Rajan cannot answer.

The arc

FromA graduate with a laptop and a cost spreadsheet.
ToA venture analyst who writes down his own conflict of interest and tells his uncle what the model had already found.

Karthik starts as the bringer of software and hard questions, and his records correct Rajan more than once. His own confidence is checked too: the all-at-once rollout he advised silences the floor, and the platform he cites turns out to be a new middle. By 2026 he is the go-between who discloses in writing that the adviser is his uncle.

The journey

  1. Inciting incidentChapter 4

    On a Saturday in November he shows Rajan three systems and a spreadsheet comparing the cost of the software with the cost of the people. He waits for more than thanks. It does not come.

  2. Tests and alliesChapter 4

    On the Sunday call he asks what Rajan saw in Erode, and whether he would have seen the same thing if he had known the man's father.

  3. Tests and alliesChapter 5

    He puts a Copenhagen buyer's questions to an AI trade assistant and reads the answers aloud. When Rajan dismisses a mill over a bad lot, he asks whether Rajan has tried it since.

  4. Tests and alliesChapter 7

    Early 2025. He runs ten years of Rajan's records through a supplier-scoring tool, which puts Senthil's mill at the top. He asks for a checklist of Rajan's instincts and is refused.

  5. MidpointChapter 18

    He is pleased when Rajan orders every system at once. In July 2025 he leaves for a venture firm in Singapore and joins the Friday meeting by video for a few weeks.

  6. Tests and alliesChapter 22

    November 2025. On a video call from Singapore he argues that machines will take everything in the middle, his uncle included.

  7. ClimaxChapter 27

    September 2026. He draws Rajan into his fund's decision, writes a note to the lead partner stating that the adviser is his uncle, and tells Rajan the screening model had already flagged two of his three objections.

Choices under pressure

A person is what they choose when it costs them.

Chapter 4

The pull. Accept his uncle's account of the Erode owner, or ask the question that may offend.

The choice. After a silence he asks whether Rajan would have seen the same thing if he had known the man's father.

The cost. Rajan does not answer.

His kindness does not stop him from asking the hard question.

Chapter 27

The pull. Everyone in the office knows the adviser is his uncle. Writing it down makes part of his enthusiasm look like a nephew's.

The choice. He writes the note that night and copies his uncle. Later he tells Rajan what the model had already found.

The cost. It costs him a little, and it shrinks his uncle's contribution.

He will put his own interest on the record and tell an unwelcome truth to someone he loves.

What they learn

  • Advising everything at once makes him one of the many hands that helped to fill the bin. Chapter 18
  • He is half right. Machines lower the costs that middlemen lived on, and the platform he cites is itself a middle. Chapter 22
  • The part of a judgement that a person adds to the machine's may be exactly the part where his own interest lives. Chapter 27

In the text

Two monsoons is a long time. Have you tried them since?

Yours is in your head, and in Weiss’s memory.

Our model compares them with software companies. So does their deck. Neither of them has a square for you.

People

  • Respectful, persistent and kind. He phones every Sunday.

    He challenges Rajan with records and questions, advises a rollout that goes wrong, and in 2026 handles him patiently into a room where both of them have to declare an interest.

What they carry

Karthik speaks for the record and the system. The book gives him its strongest case for the machine and for writing knowledge down, and the question that tests whether Rajan's instinct reads a man or only where he comes from. It also marks his limits: a rollout advised all at once, and a platform taken for the end of the middle.

Ideasdisintermediationproblem of many handsdeck

Look forThe laptop and the cost spreadsheetThe Sunday callThe supplier-scoring toolThe forty-page deck

Where they appear

in the chapter spoken of absent

  • Volume IMentioned only.
  • Part IShows Rajan three systems and then a spreadsheet: the cost of the software beside the cost of the people who do the same work.
  • Chapter 4: Why This Matters NowShows the systems and the cost spreadsheet. Leaves Rajan a login for the supplier-checking module. On the Sunday call asks what Rajan saw in Erode, and whether he would have seen the same if he had known the man's father.
  • Chapter 5: When Intelligence Became CheapPuts the Copenhagen buyer's questions to the assistant and reads the answers aloud. When Rajan dismisses the Karnataka mill, asks whether he has tried it since.
  • Chapter 7: What AI Cannot ReplaceRuns ten years of records through a supplier-scoring tool. Asks Rajan whether he would have seen the same thing in the Erode owner if he had known his father. Asks for the checklist; does not answer when refused.
  • Chapter 15: Building Real Moats in an AI WorldReads the platform's terms and tells his uncle that their promise is written down and his is not
  • Chapter 18: The AI-Native OrganisationIn November 2024 shows Rajan the software and takes the laptop home. Sends articles. Is pleased when Rajan orders everything. Joins the Friday meeting by video for the first few weeks, then only his Sunday calls.
  • Part VArgues that machines will cut out every middleman.
  • Chapter 22: Own the Layer AI Cannot DisintermediateAsks for a video call to show a chart. Explains disintermediation and cites Weiss's platform. Describes his firm's screening model and the Jakarta decision, and does not pretend to know who was right.
  • Chapter 27: The Investor’s PlaybookAsks Rajan to read the deck. Answers each objection with 'come anyway'. Writes a note to the lead partner, copied to Rajan, stating that the adviser is his uncle. Tells Rajan the screening model had already flagged two of his three problems. Sits beside him in the meeting and does not point out that the records judged Senthil better than Rajan did.
  • Chapter 28: AI-Proofing SectorsIn early 2025 ran ten years of Rajan's records through a tool that scored every supplier.

All characters →   Story map of AI-Proof →