To decide what to do about his father, which no explanation can do for him.
Stands to lose
His father, while there is still time to speak to him.
Strength
Rigour, and the honesty to see that he has been hiding behind it.
Flaw
He lets understanding feel like resolution.
Wound
Four years of silence with his father. He grew up Catholic and left the Church at nineteen. The text does not say why the silence began.
The question their story asksWhen a man can explain every second of what he feels, what is left for him to do?
Everyman. He is the modern rational viewer, and his problem is the essay's problem in one life.
The arc
FromA scientist who understands his feeling and leaves it there.
→
ToA son who has asked a hard question and written a letter.
The film makes him cry and he can name the parts of his brain that are crying. He sees that the explanation has been a hiding place. He does not rush: he calls his sister first, asks why the silence started and whether it is safe to end, then writes to his father.
part of the arc is hidden until you have read Why Devotion Needs Logic, and Logic Needs Devotion — What Hanuman Ansh Taught Me on the Way Home.
Priya takes him to Hanuman Ansh. He explains the music to himself through the first half. When the boy on screen calls for his dead mother, he cries, and he can name which parts of his brain are crying.
Walking to the Tube he tells Priya he understood every second and has still not spoken to his father in four years. He says he has been hiding behind understanding.
He does not call his father that week. He calls his sister and asks why the silence started and whether it is safe to end it. Then he writes a letter. He tells Priya only later.
later steps are hidden. They appear as you read on.
She is the first person he calls, to ask why the silence started and whether it is safe to end it.
What they carry
The author invents him for the essay's central distinction between explaining and deciding. Science can tell him why he cried. It cannot tell him what he owes his father. Reason still has work to do in the deciding.
IdeasExplaining why I feel something is one task. Deciding what to do about it is another.