NP Nithin Palal

Chhaya Deshmukh

A clerk whose whole job is to be looked at while a machine listens.

Anything later stays hidden. The site also remembers the chapters you open on this device.
File 2084-024Supporting · Witness
Role
Grade V intake clerk at the Ministry's public counter
Also called
Chhaya, the intake clerk
Work
Grade V intake clerk at the Ministry's ground-floor public counter for nine years. She has not typed at work in all that time.
Home
A flat in Sector 9 that nobody but her has a key to.
Family
Her mother, Sushila Deshmukh, who died in Chhaya's second year at the counter. A husband in transit scheduling.
Habits
Keeps her hands on the counter's edge. Nods off the beat on purpose. Takes the stairs. At the end of each shift, says one citizen's name aloud on the third-floor half-landing.
First seen
Chapter 16
Appears in
2 of 96 pieces

What drives them

Wants

To let one person a day be a whole person.

Needs

To keep what was actually said, somewhere, even if nobody will ever ask for it.

Stands to lose

Her post, if the slips are found. And the words of the people at her counter, if she keeps nothing.

Strength

Attention. She listens to all of it when her job needs none of it.

Flaw

Fear of making a record. She gave up a list once because a written thing can be requested.

Wound

Her mother's death. Hers was the first name Chhaya said on the stairs.

The question their story asksWhat can attention do when it has no power?

Witness. She can change nothing at the counter, so she hears, remembers and finally writes.

The arc

FromA clerk who says one name aloud and lets it go.
ToA clerk who writes down what people really said and keeps it secret for the rest of her service.

For nine years her only act is a name spoken on a stairwell. After the dhobi asks whether his father is in the record, she writes his sentence on the back of a paper slip and adds his name and the date, which is the part that frightens her. It becomes a habit of most weeks, and by the time she leaves there are 1,406 slips in a tin.

The journey

  1. Ordinary worldChapter 16

    She listens to Ram Lal Sonkar for ten minutes, skips the standard line and tells him plainly there is no field for his father. At the end of the shift she says his name on the half-landing.

  2. Crossing the thresholdChapter 17

    She writes down his sentence as she remembers it, then his name and the date. She does it again eleven days later, and in time most weeks, and tells no one.

Choices under pressure

A person is what they choose when it costs them.

Chapter 17

The pull. The safety of keeping nothing, or a written record that could be requested.

The choice. She writes the sentence, and then the name and date at the top.

The cost. A secret she keeps for the rest of her years in service, with nowhere to send it.

Her quiet has a limit. She will take a risk for six seconds of a stranger's speech.

What they learn

  • No rule against a thing means nobody thought of it. That is different from permission. Chapter 17

In the text

Her whole job was to be looked at while a machine listened.

People

  • Ram Lal Sonkarcitizen at her counter

    She hears him out and answers him honestly.

    His is the first sentence she writes down.

  • Samar VarmaHandler who watches from across the floor

    She notices him leave early and thinks about him.

  • Sushila Deshmukhmother, dead

    Hers was the first name Chhaya said aloud.

  • Chhaya's husbandhusband

    He is kind and does not know about the names.

  • Sujatacolleague on the second counter

    She works beside her and is told nothing.

What they carry

She is attention without power. The terminal takes the summary, and she keeps a private archive of the originals that no institution will accept.

Ideasno fieldthe ArchiveGrade V

Look forthe third-floor half-landingpaper slips with a name and a datethe tin at the back of a cupboardthe counter's edge under her hands

Where they appear

in the chapter spoken of absent

  • Chapter 16: The Intake ClerkListens to the dhobi, skips the standard line and tells him plainly there is no field for his father; says his name on the stairwell
  • Chapter 17: The DrawerTakes a paper slip, writes his sentence as she remembers it, then writes his name and the date at the top, the part that frightens her. Puts it under the pad and finishes her shift correctly. Repeats it eleven days later and then, in time, most weeks. Tells no one.

All characters →   Story map of 2084 →