NP Nithin Palal

Ashwin Menon

A polite, well-dressed stranger asking careful questions in the lane.

Anything later stays hidden. The site also remembers the chapters you open on this device.
File 2084-023Supporting · Herald
Role
A journalist who writes about administrative mechanisms
Also called
the polite man, Ashwin
Age
Forty-four.
Work
A journalist, though nobody in the lane ever learns it
Looks
Well-dressed, polite, otherwise unremarkable
Habits
Phrases his questions with great care
First seen
Chapter 84
Appears in
2 of 96 pieces, and is spoken of in 2 more

What drives them

Wants

To find the Handler who resigned over a girl named Ruhi.

Needs

To sit, once, in the room on the other side of a found original.

Stands to lose

The largest story he has ever had in his hands.

Strength

Twenty-two years of careful work. He reads the document nobody reads and finds the people it happened to.

Flaw

He believes that putting the original where it can be found is always the fix, and never sees what finding it costs the people in it.

The question their story asksWhat does an honest piece of journalism cost the people it names?

Herald. He carries the consequence of Samar's public testimony into Ruhi's lane.

The arc

FromA careful journalist sure that exposure is the remedy.
ToThe same man, with his best piece published and no idea what it cost.

He finds Samar's testimony in the Archive, argues with himself on paper, and goes to the lane. He says Ruhi's name to a woman at a tea stall and leaves thinking the afternoon failed. His piece is good and has effects, and he never learns that a mother now weighs every word before it is written down.

The journey

  1. Inciting incidentChapter 84

    A polite stranger walks through the courtyard asking by Ruhi's name and leaves without incident. Kavya spends four hours unable to put it down.

  2. ClimaxChapter 85

    His side is told. He resolves to ask only for the Handler, then says the child's name to the third person he meets. Nine weeks later his fourteen-thousand-word piece on the six-second gap runs.

  3. AftermathChapter 86

    Another of his pieces says the variance criterion changed because he found the two people it had happened to. Aisha, who filed minutes for eighteen months, lets the claim stand.

Choices under pressure

A person is what they choose when it costs them.

Chapter 85

The pull. An eight-year-old's privacy, or a piece that is more than a piece about a document.

The choice. He goes, meaning to ask only for the Handler, and when that fails he says Ruhi's name.

The cost. None that he knows of. Kavya pays it, and later artists in the unmapped subsectors stop talking to him.

He reasons honestly and still decides in favour of the story.

What they learn

  • He has spent twenty-two years on one principle, that erasure happens in the summary, and has never sat on the other side of a found original. Chapter 85

In the text

I’m looking for the Handler who resigned over a girl called Ruhi.

People

  • Fatimastranger at her stall

    She hears him out politely.

    She tells him nothing, and he takes her unchanged face for an uneventful afternoon.

  • Ruhi Nairchild named in the testimony

    He knows her name from the Archive and has never seen her.

    He speaks her name aloud in her own lane.

  • Samar Varmasubject of his piece

    They never meet. He quotes the testimony at length.

  • Kavya Nairunknown to him

    She never hears his name. Because of him she calculates before letting anything about her work be written down.

  • Aishaofficer he never meets

    He gets the credit for a change she may have caused. Neither can prove which of them moved it.

  • the Grade III Handler in Sector 6correspondent

    She writes to him after the piece and they have corresponded since.

What they carry

He is the cost of the found original. Samar's unsummarised testimony was meant as honesty; through Ashwin it becomes a stranger saying a child's name in her lane.

Ideasthe six-second gapreferenced citizennot a reform but a receiptvariance criterion

Look forthe Archive terminalthe argument written out on paper, for and againsttwelve thousand words beside a document

Where they appear

in the chapter spoken of absent

  • Chapter 84: The Polite ManAsks three people, by Ruhi's name, and leaves without incident.
  • Chapter 85: The Man Who Came LookingDecides to go and ask only for the Handler; with the third person he says Ruhi's name. Leaves thinking the afternoon failed. Publishes the piece nine weeks later.
  • Chapter 86: Aisha, InsideFound the two people the old wording had happened to, went to the sector twice, and wrote that the criterion changed because he found them.
  • Chapter 87: Kavya, UnfundedCame down the lane with the Archive record; the reason Kavya will not write a second record.

All characters →   Story map of 2084 →