NP Nithin Palal

One Rupee, Two Labels — Did Karnataka's Money for Dalits and Adivasis Reach the Last Person?

· 47 min read · Discuss · Plain text

One Rupee, Two Labels — Did Karnataka's Money for Dalits and Adivasis Reach the Last Person?

As of 22 November 2026.

In 2022 Siddaramaiah said the BJP government had betrayed Dalits by booking their fund to canals and drains. Sixteen months later his own government booked a third of it to the five guarantees. Who was the money for?

In Brief A Karnataka law of 2013, written by a Congress government, reserves 24.1% of the State's plan spending for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. Two governments since have booked part of that money to things everyone receives. From 2019 to 2023 the BJP government counted canals, drains and tap connections as Dalit and Adivasi spending, with no list of who gained. Since 2023 the Congress government has booked about a third of the fund each year to the five guarantees, which pay the same sum to every family that qualifies. The guarantees do reach SC and ST families, and the Government counts them for four schemes out of five. Neither government has shown that the money narrowed the gap the law was written to close. I set the record beside five rules, from the Constitution, Ambedkar, Rawls, Sen and Basavaṇṇa. The lesson for whoever governs next: a reserved rupee must buy what would not otherwise be bought, and the people it is reserved for must be able to check.

Money reserved for those who started behind was spent, under two governments, on things that everyone gets. The BJP booked canals that needed no beneficiary, and the Congress books guarantees that every eligible family receives. That is my judgement, and the rest of this article gives the record it rests on. Most of the figures are budget assignments reported in newspapers, and the article says so wherever it uses one. The Congress party wrote the law and later closed the door the BJP had used, and both of those facts are to its credit. The guarantees reach Dalit and Adivasi families, and the Government has counted them. I apply one standard to the Congress government of today, to the BJP government before it, to the coalition before that, and to the Union government where it shares the work.

At a glance. Each row is argued in the Parts that follow.

The rule Where it comes from What happened in Karnataka
Give special care to the one who started behind The Constitution, Article 46, and Ambedkar About a third of the fund booked each year since 2023 to guarantees that pay every eligible family the same sum1
A reserved rupee must buy what would not otherwise be bought The Planning Commission, the 2013 Act and a World Bank study Canals under the BJP2, guarantees under the Congress3. Neither government showed what the label added
Judge by the one who has least John Rawls About ₹1,537 crore a year booked to free bus travel, with no count of SC and ST riders4
Count lives, not rupees Amartya Sen No study of outcomes. Corporations for the Scheduled Castes received their whole grant for 2024-25 in its last quarter5
Let the people it is for be heard Basavaṇṇa and his Anubhava Maṇṭapa No social audit found for any year since 2013, though the Act asks for one every year6

Opening — Bengaluru, 21 April 2022: "has betrayed Dalits"

On 21 April 2022 the Leader of the Opposition in the Karnataka Assembly was Siddaramaiah. That day he said the BJP government "has betrayed Dalits and Scheduled Tribes". He was reading from a Deccan Herald report. It said ₹7,885.32 crore of money reserved for them had been spent between 2018 and 2021 on drinking water, drainage, irrigation and other works, which the law allowed the Government to count as theirs. He said this "violated the provisions of the Act" and asked for action against the officers2 7. A year earlier, when SC and ST legislators of the BJP itself had raised the same complaint, Chief Minister B.S. Yediyurappa had answered that "not even one paisa was diverted"8 2.

Thirteen months later Siddaramaiah was Chief Minister again. In August 2023, within weeks of his first budget, ₹11,144 crore of the year's SC and ST sub-plan of ₹34,294 crore was assigned to the five guarantees9 10. In July 2024 the share rose to 37%, and his answer was one line: "Through guarantees, we're providing benefits to SC/STs."3 In the same month the Legislature's own Committee on the Welfare of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes said that using the fund for general programmes "amounts to misuse and violation of the law". It said the violation had gone on for a decade, "which is punishable"11. Ten years from 2024 reaches back through both governments.

The image I carry through this article is a rupee with two labels. The State pays one rupee and writes it into its books twice: once as a canal or a guarantee, and once as money for Dalits and Adivasis. Nobody is paid twice and no cash moves between accounts. The question is what the second label added.

Four governments hold the pen in this story. A Congress government under Siddaramaiah wrote the law in 2013. A Congress and JD(S) coalition held office from May 2018 to July 2019. The BJP governed from July 2019 to May 2023, under Yediyurappa and then Basavaraj Bommai. The Congress has governed since May 2023, under Siddaramaiah until 3 June 2026 and under D.K. Shivakumar since. The Union government comes in through its own schemes, which were booked to the State's fund, and through its own share of money for SC and ST schemes.

Figure 1Thirteen years of one fund: reserved in 2013, charged to canals, then to guarantees, and sent for audit in 2026Above the line: steps that tightened or defended the reservation. Below the line: uses and objections.
Law reserves 24.1%. Congress governmentDec 2013
2018 to 2021₹7,885 crore of works counted as 'deemed' spending
Siddaramaiah, in opposition: the BJP 'has betrayed Dalits'Apr 2022
Aug 2023First ₹11,144 crore assigned to the guarantees
Clause (d), deemed spending, removedFeb 2024
Jul 2024National Commission and the Legislature's committee object
Charge cut 6% and tied to counts for four schemesMar 2025
Nov 2026New Chief Minister announces a special audit
Source: the Act, and reports cited in the article.

One limit should be stated at the start. The year-wise figures for the guarantees come from newspaper reports of budgets, action plans and ministers' replies. I have not read the State's sub-plan budget volumes. These are figures for money assigned, and they are not audited amounts spent.

Part One — What happened: the law the Congress wrote, the door it closed, and a fund that kept growing

The good in this record should be counted first, because it is real.

The idea of a sub-plan is fifty years old and began in Delhi. The Planning Commission asked every state to set apart a share of its plan for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, equal to their share of the people. Its rules of 2010 said that only schemes which "ensure direct benefits to individuals or families belonging to scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes" should count. They asked states to place the money under separate budget heads, numbered 789 and 796, "to ensure their non-divertibility to any other scheme"12. These were instructions from a planning body. A state that ignored them broke no law.

Karnataka turned the instruction into a law. The Karnataka Scheduled Castes Sub-Plan and Tribal Sub-Plan Act, 2013 was passed by a Congress government under Siddaramaiah. Karnataka was the second state to make such a law, after Andhra Pradesh3. The Act says the State must earmark each year a part of its plan "proportionate to the Scheduled Castes/Scheduled Tribe population of the State"6. By the 2011 census that is 17.15% and 6.95%, which makes 24.1%7. In 2026-27 the fund is ₹44,632 crore1.

The Act also sets the test for any scheme that is counted. Section 15 says the sub-plans shall include only schemes that secure a "direct and quantifiable benefit" to SC or ST persons, households, habitations or areas, and that have the potential to "bridge the gaps in the development"6. There are two tests in that one sentence. The first asks whether a benefit can be counted. The second asks whether it closes a distance. The rest of this article turns on the difference between them.

Section 7 decides what may be counted. The last column is my summary.

Clause What may be counted What must be shown
7(a) The whole cost of a scheme only for SC or ST persons or households6 That the scheme is for them alone
7(b) The whole cost of a scheme for SC or ST habitations, and a share in mixed ones6 Where the habitation is and who lives there
7(c) A share of a "general social sector" scheme in education, health, women and child, labour or disability, in proportion to the SC and ST population6 That the scheme is in a named sector. No list of names is asked for
7(d) A part of a work that cannot be divided, such as a canal or a road, as the Government decides. Removed in 20246 Nothing about who used the work

The Congress government closed the fourth door. Karnataka Act 6 of 2024, in force from 3 February 2024, deletes clause (d)6. The BJP government had kept it, though its own SC and ST legislators had objected8.

The fund itself has grown. It fell in the pandemic years, when the plan it is a share of shrank, and it has risen every year since 2021-22. The BJP's manifesto of 2023 said that since 2019-20 it had allocated "more than ₹1 lakh crore towards SCSP and TSP"13. The sub-plan cell's own table bears that out: the four years from 2019-20 add up to ₹1,10,623 crore. The same table shows a high share of each year's fund recorded as spent, rising under the BJP from 94% to 97%14. A word of caution belongs to every one of those percentages, and Part Three gives it.

Figure 2The sub-plan fell in 2019-21 and has grown every year since. The share spent has stayed above 92% since 2015-16₹ crore allocated. Above each bar: the share spent, where the State reports it. Dark blue: Congress governments. Grey: the Congress and JD(S) coalition. Light blue: BJP government (from July 2019). The last two bars are budget figures.
50000400003000020000100000
81%14-15
97%15-16
92%16-17
94%17-18
93%18-19
94%19-20
95%20-21
96%21-22
97%22-23
97%23-24
24-25
25-26
26-27
Source: SCSP and TSP Cell, Government of Karnataka, for 2014-15 to 2024-25. Budget figures as reported for 2025-26 and 2026-27.

The Congress government has added to the targeted side as well. The action plan of July 2024 raised the monthly aid for SC and ST candidates preparing for the civil services from ₹10,000 to ₹15,000, set ₹91 crore for laptops for postgraduate students and planned residential schools in 60 hoblis3. The 2024-25 budget, as the auditor lists it, provided ₹2,710 crore for building residential schools and hostels for four welfare departments5.

And the guarantees reach Dalit and Adivasi families. In July 2024 the Social Welfare Minister, H.C. Mahadevappa, told the Legislative Council how many15. The last column is my arithmetic.

Guarantee SC and ST beneficiaries Of whom ST Against all beneficiaries
Anna Bhagya (free grain) 101.22 lakh people15 30.16 lakh Total not given in the reply as reported
Gruha Lakshmi (₹2,000 a month) 31.12 lakh women15 8.67 lakh About 25% of some 1.23 crore women16
Gruha Jyothi (free power) 13.90 lakh households15 4.04 lakh About 8.5% of some 1.63 crore households
Yuva Nidhi (allowance to unemployed graduates) 44,538 young people15 16,262 Total not given
Shakti (free bus travel for women) No count No count Not applicable

For Gruha Lakshmi the charge can be checked against the count. At ₹2,000 a month, 31.12 lakh women cost about ₹7,469 crore a year. The sub-plan charge for Gruha Lakshmi in 2025-26 was reported as ₹7,438 crore17. That year the Government charged the fund almost exactly what SC and ST women were paid, and the count that made the check possible is to its credit.

Part Two — What happened next: two doors, two governments, and no account of what either added

The BJP's door: canals that needed no beneficiary

The ₹7,885.32 crore that Siddaramaiah quoted in 2022 is attributed to official data that I have not seen, and three things qualify it2. The years 2018 to 2021 cover two governments, the coalition and the BJP, and I found no split between them. The clause was part of the law as the Congress wrote it, so using it was lawful. And the scale was smaller than what came later: the fund's allocations for 2018-19, 2019-20 and 2020-21 add up to about ₹83,032 crore14, so ₹7,885 crore is about 9.5% of them. The percentage is mine and only indicative.

How much of a work was counted was the Government's choice. The then minister Govind Karjol said that in the pandemic the Finance Department allowed up to 50%, and later up to 100%, of a work's cost to be counted2. One year's plan charged ₹3,307 crore of Jal Jeevan Mission tap connections to the fund2. Clause (c) was in use too. The department's report for 2022-23, as one outlet reads it, shows sub-plan money booked against the Prime Minister's crop insurance scheme (₹376.90 crore) and PM Kisan (₹129.73 crore), with counts of SC and ST farmers for each18. Those are Union schemes paid to every eligible farmer. In kind that is the same act as booking Gruha Lakshmi. In size it is far smaller.

The Congress did not stop at once either. In August 2025 Mahadevappa told the Assembly that the BJP government had spent ₹8,000 crore through deemed expenditure and "the current government" ₹4,000 crore before the clause was removed19. I have seen no record behind either figure. The second is a minister's statement against his own side, which gives it some weight.

The Congress door: one rupee in three, every year

The Congress manifesto of 2023 promised the five guarantees and, in the edition I read, said nothing about this fund. It did not tell the voter that part of the guarantees' cost would be booked to it20. The BJP's manifesto claimed a record on the fund and promised nothing about how it would be used13. The JD(S) promised cheaper capital for SC and ST entrepreneurs21. No party promised to close clause (c) or clause (d).

Every budget since 2023 has assigned part of the fund to the guarantees. Where a second figure was reported for the same year, it is shown. The shares are my arithmetic on the higher figure.

Year Sub-plan (₹ crore) Assigned to the guarantees (₹ crore) Share A second reported figure (₹ crore)
2023-24 34,294 11,1449 10 32.5% None found
2024-25 39,121.46 14,730.533 37.7% 14,281, the Minister's figure in the Council15
2025-26 42,017.51 13,433.844 32.0% 11,896.84, the action plan of July 202517 22
2026-27 44,632 15,066.461 33.8% 14,198.93, in a second report of the same budget23
Figure 3About one rupee in three of the SC and ST sub-plan has been assigned to the five guarantees in every budget since 2023₹ crore. Whole bar: the sub-plan. Orange: the part assigned to the five guarantees, by the higher reported figure. The share is written above each bar. Lower figures also exist for three of the years.
40,00030,00020,00010,0000
32.5%₹34,294
whole sub-plan
₹11,144
2023-24
37.7%₹39,121
whole sub-plan
₹14,731
2024-25
32.0%₹42,018
whole sub-plan
₹13,434
2025-26
33.8%₹44,632
whole sub-plan
₹15,066
2026-27
Source: budget and action-plan figures as reported by The News Minute, Deccan Herald and Telangana Today, 2023 to 2026.

Added up, the four budgets assign between ₹51,521 crore and ₹54,375 crore to the guarantees. The addition is mine. On 19 December 2025 a BJP leader said ₹39,000 crore meant for Dalits had been "used" for guarantees in three years24. That is a party's claim. It is close to the sum of the first three budget figures, and it treats money assigned as money spent. One newspaper reported in July 2025 that the Government told the Assembly the amount finally used for the guarantees in 2024-25 was ₹9,797 crore17. I have not seen that reply. If it is right, about a third of that year's assignment was not used.

The Government heard the objection and moved part of the way. In March 2025 the Social Welfare Department, now holding counts of SC and ST beneficiaries, wanted the charge for four guarantees tied to those counts and the charge for Shakti capped at 24.1% for want of data16. The 2025-26 budget assigned about 6% less than the year before4, and the action plan went lower again, to 28% of the fund17 22. Then the 2026-27 budget set the highest figure yet1. In Gruha Lakshmi alone the charge rose to ₹9,193.85 crore1. At ₹2,000 a month that needs about 38 lakh SC and ST women on the rolls, and I found no count that high.

Figure 4The 2025-26 charge matches the count of SC and ST women. The 2026-27 charge would need about 38 lakh of them₹ crore a year. The count of 31.12 lakh SC and ST women is from July 2024. No later count was found.
What 31.12 lakh women at ₹2,000 a month would cost in a year (my arithmetic)₹7,469 crore
Charged to the sub-plan for Gruha Lakshmi, 2025-26₹7,438 crore
Charged to the sub-plan for Gruha Lakshmi, 2026-27₹9,194 crore
Source: Deccan Herald, 19 July 2024 and 7 March 2026. Telangana Today, 29 July 2025. The first bar is the author's arithmetic.

Clause (c) raises a legal question that no court has answered. It covers "general social sector schemes" and names the sectors: education, health, women and child, labour and disability6. Gruha Lakshmi fits "women and child" clearly. Yuva Nidhi may fit "labour" or "education". Free power is an energy scheme, free grain a food scheme and free bus travel a transport scheme, and none of those sectors is named. That is my reading of the words. I am not a lawyer and I have not read the rules made under the Act. In the reports I read, the Government has not said which words of the clause cover power, grain or bus travel.

The clause also fixes the size of the charge: a share of a scheme's cost in proportion to the SC and ST population, which is 24.1%. Set the charge against what the guarantees cost by the auditor's count. In 2023-24 they cost ₹34,859 crore, and ₹11,144 crore is about 32% of that. In 2024-25 they cost ₹52,526 crore, and ₹14,730.53 crore is about 28%5. Both are above 24.1%. The comparison sets a budget figure against an audited cost, so it raises a question and does not settle it. The Legislature's committee made the same point in December 2024, when it said the charge for 2024-25 should have been ₹12,532 crore16.

Why a government reaches for this fund is my inference. The auditor puts the cost of the five guarantees at about ₹52,526 crore in 2024-25, about a fifth of the State's revenue receipts5. A Finance Department that must find that sum looks first at money already set apart in the budget, and the largest such pool is this one.

What is left when the guarantees are taken out

Take the guarantee charge out of each year's fund, and compare what remains with the whole fund of 2022-23, the last year before the guarantees.

Figure 5After the guarantees, less is left in the sub-plan than the whole fund held in 2022-23₹ crore, not adjusted for prices. Grey: the whole sub-plan in 2022-23. Blue: each later year's sub-plan less the money assigned to the guarantees, by the higher reported figure. The subtraction is the author's.
35000300002500020000150001000050000
₹30,2642022-23whole sub-plan, before the guarantees
₹23,1502023-24
₹24,3912024-25
₹28,5842025-26
₹29,5662026-27
Source: SCSP and TSP Cell, Government of Karnataka, and budget figures as reported, 2023 to 2026.

In 2026-27 the remainder is about ₹29,566 crore, against ₹30,263.77 crore for the whole fund in 2022-2314. The headline figure for SC and ST welfare has grown by 47% in four years, and the part not booked to the guarantees has not grown at all in plain rupees. This is not a measure of targeted spending. The fund of 2022-23 also carried canals and shares of farm schemes. A true comparison would split each year's fund by clause, in amounts spent, allowing for prices. I could not find that split for any year.

The people who objected

The objections came from inside both parties and from outside both. On 9 July 2024 the National Commission for Scheduled Castes wrote to the State's Chief Secretary and asked for a report on the use of ₹14,730.53 crore for the guarantees11. I have found no reply. The Leader of the Opposition in the Council, Chalavadi Narayanaswamy, put the case in seven words: "Guarantees are being given irrespective of caste."25 In November 2025, as Deccan Herald reported him, he said of the Congress and the fund: "They brought it and gobbled it too."26 More than one newspaper reports that Dalit leaders inside the Congress have asked their own Chief Minister to scrap clause (c)25 1. Under the BJP, its own SC and ST legislators had made the same complaint about clause (d)8. Each time, the people who saw the cost belonged to the communities the fund was for. Each time, their own government answered that nothing was wrong.

Part Three — What it should have been: five rules for a fund kept for those who started behind

The fund exists because in India birth decided a person's worth for a very long time. Tiruvaḷḷuvar said otherwise about two thousand years ago:

piṟappokkum ellā uyirkkum ciṟappovvā / ceytoḻil vēṟṟumai yāṉ

By birth all men are equal. Differences in their action render their worth unequal.

Tirukkuṟaḷ 972, in the English printed on thirukkural.net.

A law that reserves money by caste is an admission that the couplet was not obeyed. The five rules below are what I think such a law asks of a ruler. Each comes from a source anyone can check. Each is then put to the record.

Give special care to the one who started behind

Article 46 of the Constitution is a Directive Principle. It reads: "The State shall promote with special care the educational and economic interests of the weaker sections of the people, and, in particular, of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes, and shall protect them from social injustice and all forms of exploitation."27 The phrase that matters is "special care". Equal treatment is owed to every citizen. Special care is something more.

On 25 November 1949 Dr B.R. Ambedkar told the Constituent Assembly why. "On the 26th of January 1950, we are going to enter into a life of contradictions. In politics we will have equality and in social and economic life we will have inequality. In politics we will be recognizing the principle of one man one vote and one vote one value."28 Then he asked: "How long shall we continue to live this life of contradictions?"28

A guarantee belongs to the first half of his sentence. It pays every woman who qualifies the same ₹2,000, as every citizen has the same vote. That equal treatment is good in itself. The sub-plan was written for the second half, the social and economic inequality. When the first is counted as the second, the contradiction is answered in the accounts and nowhere else. That is my reading.

The Government's best case deserves its strongest words, and some of them are mine. Universal schemes miss fewer poor people than targeted ones, because nobody has to prove a caste or an income to a clerk. About a quarter of Gruha Lakshmi's women are SC or ST, which matches their share of the people. And ₹2,000 is a larger part of a poorer household's income, so the same payment closes some of the distance even when everyone receives it. All of that may be true. None of it has been measured for Karnataka, and none of it is special care. It is equal care, booked as special.

A reserved rupee must buy what would not otherwise be bought

The Planning Commission asked for the money to be kept "non-divertible", and the 2013 Act asks that it "bridge the gaps"12 6. Economists have studied what an earmark does when a government holds the purse. Three World Bank economists looked at loans that donors marked for particular sectors. A government, they wrote, "could render earmarked aid fungible by reducing its own resources in the sector that receives aid"29. They found that loans to agriculture, energy and education were in large part diverted in this way, and "only loans to the transport and communication sector are fully spent on the purposes intended by the donor"29. The study is about aid to countries, not about Karnataka. I use it as a lens: an earmark protects a group only when it pays for something that would not have been bought without it.

Figure 6One scheme, two labels: a share of the cost is booked under the sub-plan, and every woman who qualifies receives the same sumThe bar is the yearly cost of one guarantee. The accounting is done for the scheme as a whole. No single payment carries a label, and no money moves between accounts. The share shown is the 24.1% that clause (c) allows.
Cost of the scheme for one year
Booked under the general budgetBooked under the SC and ST sub-plan

Every woman who qualifies receives ₹2,000 a month, whatever her community.The label changes which part of the budget the cost is shown under.It does not change what any woman receives.

Source: the author's reading of section 7(c) of the 2013 Act. Not a finding of the auditor.

Put that test to both governments. A canal would have been dug without the sub-plan, and under clause (d) nobody had to show that a Dalit family drew water from it. A guarantee is paid to every woman who qualifies, whatever her community. So in both cases the general budget was relieved of a cost, and the law still showed 24.1% booked for SCs and STs. The guarantee is better than the canal on the first test of section 15, because it is a direct and counted benefit to a named woman. On the second test, whether the label added anything, the two governments are in the same place. I cannot name a hostel, a scholarship or a loan scheme that went short because of either, and no record I read names one.

The Government has a serious reply. A department official called it "a zero-sum game": once 24.1% is reserved by law, some of it must flow through general schemes, because targeted schemes cannot absorb it all25. I accept that as a fact about how the State works today. It is an argument for repairing the targeted schemes. It is not evidence that the reservation was honoured.

Judge by the one who has least

John Rawls asked that "social and economic inequalities are to be arranged so that they are to the greatest benefit of the least advantaged"30. A fund for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes is an attempt at that rule, and the right way to judge it is to stand where the least advantaged person in it stands.

Stand in a hamlet with no bus route. About ₹1,537 crore a year of the fund is booked to Shakti, the free bus travel for women4 1. A bus conductor does not record caste, so nobody knows how many of those journeys are made by SC and ST women. A BJP member of the Council from a Scheduled Tribe, Shantaram Siddi, said that tribal areas have no bus routes to ride on15. That is one member's statement. Nothing on record answers it.

Stand where a landless labourer stands. She is counted among the 101.22 lakh SC and ST people who draw free grain15. Grain does not become land. Stand where a tenant stands, with no meter in her name. SC and ST households are about 8.5% of Gruha Jyothi's homes on the Government's counts, against 24.1% of the people. A share of the population is not a share of households with a meter, so this does not prove that free power under-reaches them. It may mean fewer meters in their names or more tenants. It is a question for the energy department. And stand in a forest settlement instead of a town colony. On the State-wide counts the ST share of recipients is close to its share of the two groups together. State-wide counts cannot show the difference between the colony and the forest. Section 6 of the Act requires details by district, village and beneficiary6. I found none published.

The same test was failed under the BJP in a plainer way. A canal or a tap connection booked to the fund under clause (d) came with no list of who used it2. Nobody could say whether the least advantaged gained at all.

Count lives, not rupees

Amartya Sen opened Development as Freedom with this sentence: "Development can be seen, it is argued here, as a process of expanding the real freedoms that people enjoy." He set it against "narrower views of development, such as identifying development with the growth of gross national product, or with the rise in personal incomes"31. Payments, counts and allocations are what a state can show quickly. Whether a Dalit girl finishes college, or an Adivasi family owns the land it farms, is what the fund was for.

On that test the record is nearly blank, under every government. I found no study that measures whether SC and ST families in Karnataka are better schooled, housed or employed because of this fund. The State's own figure for "spent" counts a rupee when it leaves the treasury, and under the BJP it included canals counted as Dalit spending. So the BJP's 97% spent14 says how fast the label was used. It does not say how lives changed.

The auditor's review of 2024-25 shows the gap between leaving the treasury and arriving. On 30 March 2025, a day before the year closed, the Social Welfare Department moved ₹145 crore into deposit accounts of a development corporation and a schools society. The auditor calls such year-end transfers "mere parking of funds"5. The corporations under the Social Welfare Department, which lend to Scheduled Caste borrowers, received their whole year's grant of ₹425 crore in the last three months5. The audit does not say which of these sums were booked under the sub-plan, so I do not tie them to it. A young Dalit man who wants a loan to open a workshop does not care how the money was labelled. He cares that the lender had nothing to lend for nine months.

Figure 7Corporations under the Social Welfare Department received their whole year's grant in the last three months of 2024-25₹ crore released to welfare corporations in 2024-25. Light: released in the first nine months. Orange: released in the last quarter. The auditor does not say whether these grants were booked under the SC and ST sub-plan.
Social Welfare Department (Scheduled Castes)₹425100% in the last quarter
Tribal Welfare Department (Scheduled Tribes)₹28₹82.575% in the last quarter
Backward Classes Welfare Department₹84₹252.7575% in the last quarter
Source: CAG State Finances report 2024-25, Appendix 2.15.

The Union government's part is on the same page of the audit. Under its scheme PM-AJAY it allotted ₹398.95 crore to Karnataka for 2022 to 2025. The first instalment of ₹23.77 crore, received in 2022-23 under the BJP government, was not used, so later instalments were withheld, and only ₹6.01 crore came in 2024-255. Two State governments and the Union's release rule share that result. And for the anganwadi nutrition scheme the two official ledgers disagree by about ₹410 crore on what the State passed on in 2024-25. The auditor asked the Finance Department why and was waiting for a reply5.

Figure 8Two official ledgers disagree by ₹410 crore on what was passed on for anganwadi nutrition₹ crore, State's share of Saksham Anganwadi and Poshan 2.0, 2024-25. The auditor asked for the reasons and was awaiting a reply.
State's share due in 2024-25₹727.90 crore
Passed on, by the State's accounts (VLC figures)₹311.99 crore
Passed on, by the scheme's own account (SNA report on PFMS)₹721.98 crore
Source: CAG State Finances report 2024-25, Table 2.18.

A study is now planned. On 29 October 2026 the cabinet is reported to have approved a survey called Project K-Monitor, to cover the five guarantees in all 224 constituencies with about 1.6 lakh respondents32. If it reports separately for SC and ST households, it could answer the question this article cannot. A planned survey is not a result.

Let the people it is for be heard

In twelfth-century Kalyāṇa, Basavaṇṇa gathered people of every caste in a hall for discussion, the Anubhava Maṇṭapa. His biographer H. Thipperudraswamy writes that "The Gates of Dharma were thrown open to all without any barriers of caste, creed or sex."33 One of Basavaṇṇa's vachanas, in the English the Sahitya Akademi prints, says where caste really lies33:

The man who slays is a pariah / The man who eats the carrion is a low-caste person / Where is the caste here-where? / Our Kudala Sanga's sharana / Who loves all living things / He is the well-born one.

Basavaṇṇa, vachana, in H. Thipperudraswamy, Basaveshwara, Sahitya Akademi, page 27.

I take one rule from that hall for a fund like this one. The people it is kept for must be in the room where its use is judged. The 2013 Act agrees. It asks the Nodal Agency to "facilitate at least annual social auditing" of the money, to keep details by scheme, district, village and beneficiary, to run a web portal, and to place a report on outcomes before the Legislature every year6. I looked on the sub-plan cell's website and in press reports and found no social audit published for any year since 2013, under any party. That is a missing public record. It does not prove that no audit was done.

The voices were there. SC and ST legislators of the BJP objected to the canals, and were told that "not even one paisa was diverted"8. Dalit leaders in the Congress objected to the guarantees, and were told by the Minister that it was neither misuse nor diversion19. A national commission wrote a letter11. A committee of the Legislature called it misuse11. Not one of them was given a ledger that showed what the label had added.

Part Four — The gap, and who owns it

The table puts each rule to each government. The judgements in it are mine, from the record above.

The rule BJP government, 2019 to 2023 Congress government, 2023 to now Union government
Special care Fund fell for two years in the pandemic, then recovered14 Fund grew every year. About a third booked to equal-sum schemes1 Its farm schemes were booked to the State's fund18
Buy what would not otherwise be bought Canals and tap connections counted, with no beneficiary2 Guarantees counted, with beneficiaries but no addition shown3 Not tested here
Judge by the one who has least No list of who used the works Counts for four schemes. None for Shakti15 Not tested here
Count lives, not rupees 94% to 97% recorded as spent, canals included14 No outcome study. A survey planned32 PM-AJAY money withheld after the first instalment went unused5
Let them be heard Own SC and ST legislators overruled8 Own Dalit leaders overruled. Closed clause (d)6 No reply to the Commission's letter found

The BJP government used the weaker door. A canal booked to a Dalit fund carried no name, and it kept that door open when its own legislators asked it to close it. It also let the fund fall in rupees for two years, though a fixed share of a shrinking plan explains much of that. Its claim of "more than ₹1 lakh crore" is true and says less than it sounds, because the law fixes the share and any government that passes a budget allocates it.

The Congress government wrote the law, closed the weaker door and counted the beneficiaries of four schemes. It then booked a larger share of the fund, in rupees and as a share, to schemes that every eligible family receives, and it has not said which words of the law cover three of them. On the reported figures its amounts are several times the BJP's. The two sets of figures are not matched, so the difference in scale is an order of magnitude and no more.

The Union government booked its own farm schemes to the State's fund in the BJP years and withholds its own money when the State fails to spend the first instalment. I have not tested the Union's own SC and ST budget by these rules, and until that is done the Minister's claim that the Union does the same stands as his19.

My judgement is that both state governments treated the reservation as a label to be filled, and neither treated it as a distance to be closed. The Congress government did more good with the label, because a guarantee reaches a named woman and a canal does not. It also used the label on a far larger scale. What I may have missed: an outcome study I did not find, a social audit that was done and not published, and the State's own budget volumes, which might settle the figures that two newspapers report differently.

Part Five — The lesson: what a future government can keep

None of these repairs is free. If the guarantees could no longer be booked to the fund, the law would still require 24.1% of the plan to be booked for SCs and STs, and about ₹15,000 crore a year of new targeted spending would have to be found. That means more borrowing, less of something else, or a change made over several years. Each repair below is my proposal.

The repair Who can act Where it is done How it can fail
Write a rule for the second test of section 15: count a general scheme only for what SC and ST families receive above the general entitlement The State Council, by a rule under the Act. The Legislature, by amendment Section 15 states the aim and leaves the measure open6 Departments cannot design ₹15,000 crore of targeted schemes in a year, and the money is parked
Publish which words of clause (c) cover each scheme, with the legal opinion relied on The Nodal Agency and the Law Department Not done, on what I found An opinion written to fit a decision already taken
Cap each year's charge at the lower of 24.1% of the scheme's cost and the counted beneficiaries times the entitlement Social Welfare and Finance Departments Karnataka itself, for Gruha Lakshmi in 2025-2617 The counts come from departments that gain from them, so they need an outside check
Book nothing to Shakti until a survey of riders gives a share, with bus routes mapped by district Transport and Social Welfare Departments The department proposed a cap for want of data in 202516 A survey costs money, and hamlets without buses stay unserved
Hold the social audit the Act already asks for, in the gram sabha, with the records open The Nodal Agency, with panchayats The rural jobs law: "The Gram Sabha shall conduct regular social audits of all the projects under the Scheme"34 An audit held once for show, with records kept back
Make up any unspent money in the next year, and count money as spent only when it reaches a person The Legislature and the Finance Department Telangana's law of 2017 says unspent money "shall be compensated in the next financial year"35 The backlog rolls forward and grows
Issue the special audit as a written order, with a date, covering both clauses and every government since 2014, published in full The Chief Minister and the State Council Announced on 12 November 2026. No order seen36 Institutions chosen by the audited may find little

The Legislature's committee asked in 2024 for clause (c) to be scrapped11. I have not put that in the table as a separate row. Closing the door at once, while targeted schemes spend as they do now, would turn a problem of labels into a problem of unspent money.

If you are twenty today, and Dalit or Adivasi, the fund was written for you, and you have never been shown what it bought. If you are twenty and neither, you will one day pay for whatever this generation did not fix. The lesson I would leave you is the habit the law already asks for and no government has kept: when a budget says a sum is for a people, ask to see the list of what that sum bought that would not have been bought anyway. Ask it of the party you vote for as hard as of the one you do not. Both parties in this story were asked by their own members, and both said nothing was wrong.

Ending — Vikasa Soudha, 12 November 2026: "no point in blaming those who were there earlier"

On Thursday 12 November 2026 the council that runs the fund met again, under a different Chief Minister. D.K. Shivakumar said the Government's intention "has always been to ensure that the funds allocated for SC/ST welfare are spent properly"36. A group of ministers under the Deputy Chief Minister, G. Parameshwara, is to review the two sub-plans with the Finance Department, looking at overlapping benefits, new schemes and how the hostels are run. PTI reports that it was to report within two to three days36. The council also agreed to Parameshwara's proposal for a special audit of what has been spent over the years and how many lives it has changed36. Every beneficiary is to be documented, to prevent duplication36. And the Chief Minister added: "There is no point in blaming those who were there earlier."37

None of the reports of the meeting mentions the guarantees or clause (c). I have seen no written order for the audit, so I call it announced. As of 22 November 2026 I have found no report of what the group of ministers recommended.

The announcement is to the Government's credit. The Chief Minister's sentence is half right. Blame is cheap, and this article has tried to spread it evenly. But a fund is not repaired by forgetting who used it and how. The man who said in 2022 that the BJP had betrayed Dalits then did the same thing through a wider door, and his own party had once written the law that both doors were cut in. If those who come next do not study those who were there earlier, they will do it a third time, through a door nobody has named yet.

The law never promised a Dalit woman a second ₹2,000. It promised that a share of the plan would close the distance between her and her neighbour. If the payment both of them receive is counted as that share, what is left to close the distance?

More from Satyameva Jayate · Karnataka: The Blank Line in the Passbook — Is a Karnataka Guarantee a Right, or a Ruler's Gift? and The Bee and the Flower — What May a Ruler Take from Karnataka, and What Must He Tell?


Words to keep

  • One rupee, two labels.
  • A canal needed no beneficiary. A guarantee needs no caste.
  • Equal care, booked as special.
  • An earmark protects a people only when it buys what would not have been bought without it.
  • Blame is cheap. Forgetting is dearer.

Sources

  1. "Karnataka Budget 2026-27: State govt allocates Rs 15,066 crore for guarantees from SCSP/TSP", Deccan Herald, 7 March 2026. https://www.deccanherald.com/india/karnataka/karnataka-budget-2026-27-state-govt-allocates-rs-15066-crore-for-guarantees-from-scsptsp-3922489
  2. "Rs 7K-cr SC/ST funds 'diverted' for infra works in Karnataka", Deccan Herald, April 2022. https://www.deccanherald.com/india/karnataka/st-funds-diverted-for-infra-works-in-karnataka-1102213.html
  3. "Govt to use 37% of SC/ST funds for guarantees", Deccan Herald, 6 July 2024. https://deccanherald.com/amp/story/india%2Fkarnataka%2Fgovt-to-use-37-of-sc-st-funds-for-guarantees-3094766
  4. "Karnataka Budget takes away 6% less from SC/ST funds for guarantees this year", Deccan Herald, March 2025. https://www.deccanherald.com/india/karnataka/karnataka-budget-takes-away-6-less-from-scst-funds-for-guarantees-this-year-3439261
  5. "Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India on State Finances for the year 2024-25, Government of Karnataka (Report No. 2 of 2026)", CAG, tabled 26 March 2026. Appendix 2.15 and Table 2.18 are cited. https://cag.gov.in/en/audit-report/details/124514
  6. Karnataka Scheduled Castes Sub-Plan and Tribal Sub-Plan (Planning, Allocation and Utilization of Financial Resources) Act, 2013 (Karnataka Act 65 of 2013), as amended by Karnataka Act 6 of 2024. Copy hosted by PRS Legislative Research. Sections 2, 6, 7, 13, 15 and 26 are cited. https://prsindia.org/files/bills_acts/acts_states/karnataka/2013/2013KR65.pdf
  7. "SC/ST fund diversion: Siddaramaiah slams BJP govt", Deccan Herald, 21 April 2022. https://www.deccanherald.com/amp/story/india%2Fkarnataka%2Fst-fund-diversion-siddaramaiah-slams-bjp-govt-1102618.html
  8. "BSY says not even a paisa diverted from SC/ST funds", Deccan Herald, 2021. https://www.deccanherald.com/state/karnataka-politics/bsy-says-not-even-a-paisa-diverted-from-sc/st-funds-1004274.html
  9. "Karnataka govt under fire over decision to use SC/ST funds for other schemes", The News Minute, 4 August 2023. https://www.thenewsminute.com/karnataka/karnataka-govt-under-fire-over-decision-use-scst-funds-other-schemes-180644
  10. "Siddaramaiah government looks to use ₹11,000 crore SCP/TSP funds to implement poll guarantees", The South First, 2 August 2023. https://thesouthfirst.com/karnataka/siddaramaiah-government-looks-to-use-₹11000-crore-scp-tsp-funds-to-implement-poll-guarantees
  11. "Karnataka legislature committee slams state government for alleged misuse of SC/ST funds", The News Minute, 26 July 2024. https://www.thenewsminute.com/amp/story/karnataka/karnataka-legislature-committee-slams-state-government-for-alleged-misuse-of-scst-funds
  12. "Revised Guidelines for Implementation of Scheduled Castes Sub-Plan and Tribal Sub-Plan", report of the Task Force chaired by Dr Narendra Jadhav, Planning Commission, 2010. Pages 6 and 12 are cited. https://niti.gov.in/sites/default/files/2019-12/SCSP_TSP_Revised_Guidelines_2010.pdf
  13. Bharatiya Janata Party, Karnataka Assembly election manifesto 2023 (English). PDF page 18, printed page 04, is cited.
  14. SCSP and TSP Cell, Government of Karnataka, table of allocation and expenditure from 2014-15, read in November 2026. https://www.scsptsp.karnataka.gov.in/
  15. "Karnataka minister defends diversion of SC/ST funds to guarantees", Deccan Herald, 19 July 2024. https://www.deccanherald.com/india/karnataka/karnataka-minister-defends-diversion-of-scst-funds-to-guarantees-3113505
  16. "Armed with data, govt may allocate SC/ST sub-plan funds for 4 guarantees based on community numbers", Deccan Herald, 1 March 2025. https://www.deccanherald.com/amp/story/india%2Fkarnataka%2Farmed-with-data-govt-may-allocate-scst-sub-plan-funds-for-4-guarantees-based-on-community-numbers-3427205
  17. "Congress government under fire again for diverting SC/ST welfare funds to guarantee schemes", Telangana Today, 29 July 2025. https://telanganatoday.com/congress-government-under-fire-again-for-diverting-sc-st-welfare-funds-to-guarantee-schemes
  18. "From PM Kisan to guarantees: how Dalit and tribal welfare funds are spent in Karnataka", The South First, 9 July 2024. https://thesouthfirst.com/karnataka/from-pm-kisan-to-guarantees-how-dalit-and-tribal-welfare-funds-are-spent-in-karnataka/
  19. "Karnataka minister warns of action against departments not furnishing SC/ST funds data", PTI in The Week, 20 August 2025. https://www.theweek.in/wire-updates/national/2025/08/20/mds20-ka-scst-funds-minister.html and "Diversion of SC/ST funds: Karnataka minister assures invoking penal provisions", Deccan Herald, August 2025. https://www.deccanherald.com/india/karnataka/diversion-of-scst-funds-karnataka-minister-assures-invoking-penal-provisions-3689556
  20. "Assembly Election Karnataka, Manifesto 2023: Sarva Janangada Shanthiya Thota", Karnataka Pradesh Congress Committee, 2023. 25-page edition.
  21. Janata Dal (Secular), "Janata Pranalike 2023" (Kannada). Page 9 is cited. The English is the author's.
  22. "HCM defends Rs 11k cr SC/ST funds for guarantees", Deccan Herald, 28 July 2025. https://www.deccanherald.com/india/karnataka/hcm-defends-rs-11k-cr-sc-st-funds-for-guarantees-3652892
  23. "Karnataka: Diversion of SC/ST funds for guarantee schemes sparks outrage against state government", Organiser, 24 March 2026. https://organiser.org/2026/03/24/345342/bharat/karnataka-diversion-of-sc-st-funds-for-guarantee-schemes-sparks-outrage-against-state-government/
  24. "Rs 39,000 crore meant for Dalits used for guarantees: K'taka BJP demands minister's resignation", IANS in Lokmat Times, 19 December 2025. https://www.lokmattimes.com/national/rs-39000-crore-meant-for-dalits-used-for-guarantees-ktaka-bjp-demands-ministers-resignation/amp
  25. "SC/ST funds for guarantees: Karnataka's Opposition cries misuse, Congress government not amused", Deccan Herald, March 2025. https://www.deccanherald.com/amp/story/india%2Fkarnataka%2Fscst-funds-for-guarantees-karnatakas-opposition-cries-misuse-congress-government-not-amused-3428013
  26. "SCSP/TSP funds: Congress brought it, gobbled it too, says Chalavadi", Deccan Herald, 28 November 2025. https://www.deccanherald.com/india/karnataka/scsptsp-funds-congress-brought-it-gobbled-it-too-says-chalavadi-3813850
  27. Constitution of India, Article 46, adopted in the Constituent Assembly on 23 November 1948 as Draft Article 37. https://www.constitutionofindia.net/articles/article-46-promotion-of-educational-and-economic-interests-of-scheduled-castes-scheduled-tribes-and-other-weaker-sections/
  28. Dr B.R. Ambedkar, speech in the Constituent Assembly, 25 November 1949, as reproduced by the Supreme Court Observer. https://www.scobserver.in/journal/the-doctors-wise-words-on-25-november-1949/
  29. Tarhan Feyzioglu, Vinaya Swaroop and Min Zhu, "A Panel Data Analysis of the Fungibility of Foreign Aid", The World Bank Economic Review, volume 12, number 1, 1998, pages 29 to 58. Pages 30 and 54 are cited. https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/514331468149391238/pdf/772610JRN0WBER0Box0377301B00PUBLIC0.pdf
  30. John Rawls, A Theory of Justice, Harvard University Press, 1971, page 302 (revised edition 1999, page 266), as quoted in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, "Original Position", supplement on the difference principle. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/original-position/difference-principle.html
  31. Amartya Sen, Development as Freedom, Oxford University Press, 1999, Introduction, page 3. https://semilleropacifico.uniandes.edu.co/images/document/economia/Development-as-freedom_Introduction-and-Chapter_1.pdf
  32. "Karnataka Approves Project K-Monitor Survey", GKToday, 29 October 2026. https://www.gktoday.in/karnataka-approves-project-k-monitor-survey/
  33. H. Thipperudraswamy, Basaveshwara, Sahitya Akademi, New Delhi, first published 1975, reprint 2017. Pages 8 and 27 are cited. https://sahitya-akademi.gov.in/pdf/Basaveshwara.pdf
  34. Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act, 2005, section 17(2). https://indiankanoon.org/doc/27355703/
  35. Telangana State Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes Special Development Fund (Planning, Allocation and Utilization of Financial Resources) Act, 2017. Copy hosted by PRS Legislative Research. https://prsindia.org/files/bills_acts/acts_states/telangana/2017/2017Telangana18.pdf
  36. "Group of Ministers to review implementation of schemes for SC/ST: CM Shivakumar", PTI in The Week, 12 November 2026. https://www.theweek.in/wire-updates/national/2026/11/12/group-of-ministers-to-review-implementation-of-schemes-for-sc-st-cm-shivakumar.html
  37. Report of the meeting of the State SC and ST Development Council of 12 November 2026, The Bengaluru Live, 13 November 2026. https://thebengalurulive.com/karnataka-to-write-to-pm-ninth-schedule-sc-st-quota-hike-social-audit-scsp-tsp/

How I wrote this

What I read in the original. The 2013 Act with its 2024 amendment, and the Telangana Act of 2017, both in copies hosted by PRS Legislative Research and not in the Gazette. The Planning Commission's guidelines of 2010. The sub-plan cell's table of allocation and spending. The Comptroller and Auditor General's report on Karnataka's State Finances for 2024-25: the cost of the guarantees, the review of the Social Welfare grant, the releases to corporations, the PM-AJAY finding and the anganwadi ledgers. Article 46. Section 17 of the rural employment guarantee law. The World Bank study on fungibility. The three main parties' manifestos of 2023.

What rests on press reports. Every year-wise figure for money assigned to the guarantees. These are budget and action-plan figures and not amounts spent. The beneficiary counts tabled in the Legislative Council. The National Commission's letter and the Legislature committee's two reports. The figure of ₹7,885.32 crore for 2018 to 2021, the Jal Jeevan Mission charge and the farm schemes booked in 2022-23. The statements of Siddaramaiah, Yediyurappa, Karjol, Mahadevappa, Narayanaswamy, Siddi and Shivakumar. The council meeting of 12 November 2026. Project K-Monitor, from a summary of the cabinet's decision. The split of 24.1% into 17.15% and 6.95%, since the Act prints no percentage.

What I have not seen or could not confirm. The State's sub-plan budget volumes, and so any figure for what was finally spent on the guarantees under the sub-plan, including the reported ₹9,797 crore for 2024-25. Why two reports differ on the 2026-27 figure. Which words of clause (c) the Government relies on for each guarantee, and the rules made under the Act. Whether the yearly social audits and reports that the Act requires were done in any year. Whether the audit findings on the welfare departments concern money booked under the sub-plan. The data behind ₹7,885.32 crore and its split between the coalition and the BJP. The Minister's figures of ₹8,000 crore and ₹4,000 crore. The State's reply to the National Commission. Any court order on the practice. Any count of hostel seats, scholarships, land grants or anganwadi beneficiaries against those eligible. Any written order for the special audit, or the group of ministers' report. The units of the sub-plan cell's table, which I read as crore of rupees.

Quotations. The Act, the Planning Commission, the audit, Article 46, the rural jobs law, the Telangana Act and the manifestos are quoted from the documents. Ambedkar's words are from a reproduction of his speech of 25 November 1949, not from the printed Debates. Rawls is quoted from A Theory of Justice (page 302 of the first edition, 266 of the revised) as the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy prints it. Sen is quoted from the Introduction of Development as Freedom. The Tirukkuṟaḷ couplet and its English are from thirukkural.net, which does not name the translator. Basavaṇṇa's vachana is from H. Thipperudraswamy's Basaveshwara (Sahitya Akademi, first published 1975), which prints the English without the Kannada and does not name the translator of this vachana. Ministers, leaders and the committee are quoted as newspapers reported them.

Readings that are mine. The five rules as rules for this fund. The image of one rupee under two labels, and the use of the fungibility study as a lens. That neither government showed what the label added. The reading of clause (c) against the guarantees. All arithmetic: the shares of the fund, the four-budget totals, the charge as a share of the guarantees' audited cost, the Gruha Lakshmi check, the Gruha Jyothi share, the remainder after the guarantees, the 9.5% for deemed spending and the sum of the BJP years. The table of governments against rules, and the judgement in Part Four. The repairs, and the estimate that the first would need about ₹15,000 crore a year. The inference about why the Finance Department reaches for this fund.

How the same test was applied to others. I put one question to every government: was money reserved under the Act booked to spending that was not designed for SCs and STs alone, and was it shown to close a gap? The record says yes to the first for both the BJP and the Congress, through different clauses and on different scales, and shows neither proving the second. I set the coalition year apart where the figures allowed. The test of the Union government is thin. I recorded its schemes booked to the State's fund and the PM-AJAY money withheld, and I did not test its own budget.

What I did not do. I did not speak to hostel students, borrowers from the corporations, anganwadi workers, women who receive the guarantees or families in hamlets without buses. I did not put questions to the Nodal Agency or to the Social Welfare, Finance or Energy Departments, and none of them has had a chance to reply. I have not taken a lawyer's opinion on clause (c). The article names no person as accused of an offence.

This article replaces an earlier one. It replaces "One Rupee, Two Ledgers", published on 17 November 2026. The figures are the same. The judgement now rests on five stated rules, and the earlier article's glossary and lens tables are gone.

↑ Back to top

Discuss

Loading the discussion…

More in Satyameva Jayate