# The Bee and the Flower — What May a Ruler Take from Karnataka, and What Must He Tell?

By Nithin Palal · 22 November 2026 · 26 min read
Section: Satyameva Jayate · Series: Karnataka
Source: https://nithinpalal.com/satyameva-jayate/karnataka/public-finance-what-may-a-ruler-take

> Karnataka's finance department said the money was not there. The cabinet spent anyway, and then milk rose ₹8 a litre and bus fares by up to 35%. An old rule says a ruler should take as a bee takes honey. This is how far the state has moved from it.
**Satyameva Jayate · Karnataka**

*As of 19 November 2026.*

[Satyameva Jayate](https://nithinpalal.com/satyameva-jayate) › [Karnataka](https://nithinpalal.com/satyameva-jayate/karnataka)

**Karnataka's finance department said the money was not there. The cabinet spent anyway, and then milk rose ₹8 a litre and bus fares by up to 35%. An old rule says a ruler should take as a bee takes honey. This is how far the state has moved from it.**

**In Brief:** *Karnataka's budget for 2026-27 sits just inside two legal limits and outside the third. Its finance department counts ₹36,136 crore of unpaid bills that no limit measures. Interest now costs more than the five guarantees. Since 2024 the state has raised six prices and taxes by order, each with a stated reason, and none by a vote. I set this record beside five old rules for a treasury, from Manu, Kauṭilya, Tiruvaḷḷuvar, Ibn Khaldun and Adam Smith. Both governments since 2019 fail most of them, in different ways. The lesson for a future finance minister fits in one line: cost the promise before the vote, raise prices in small steps and in the open, and publish what you owe.*

**A ruler may take what the people can bear, must say what he takes it for, and must not hide what he owes. Karnataka's governments since 2019 kept the first rule in part and broke the other two.** That is my judgement, and the rest of this article gives the record it rests on. The record comes from the state's auditor, from budget summaries, and from press reports of orders I have not read. The standard is older than any of them. I state it as mine, and I apply it to the BJP government of 2019 to 2023, to the Congress government since 2023 and to the Union government.

**At a glance.** Each row is argued in the Parts that follow.

| The rule | Where it comes from | What happened in Karnataka |
|---|---|---|
| Take little, and by degrees | Manusmṛti 7.129 | Charges were frozen for 5 to 22 years, then raised by up to 35% in a day |
| Take in the open | Adam Smith, 1776 | Six rises by order. One decision was held back for 23 days until a poll was over |
| Guard the treasury before you promise | Arthaśāstra 2.8.1 | The guarantees were not costed before the vote. Works were approved far beyond the budget |
| Do not hide what you owe | My own rule, from the motto of this series | ₹36,136 crore of unpaid bills sits outside every legal limit |
| Do not send the bill to the unborn | Jefferson, 1789 | The state has borrowed to meet running costs in every year since 2023-24 |

## Opening — A note, a cabinet and a litre of milk

On 17 September 2026 Karnataka's finance department wrote a note on a file numbered FD 317 EXP6/2026**¹**. The file carried a proposal for 15,000 km of village roads at a cost of ₹10,000 crore. The note advised against it for now. According to the two reports that quote it, the department wrote that pending bills in four departments stood at ₹36,136 crore, and that the state had "virtually exhausted" its borrowing capacity for the year**¹ ²**. One sentence is quoted in full: "It would be prudent to be realistic regarding the funding envelope that is available."**²**

The next day the cabinet met in Mangaluru. It was reported to have approved the road scheme as part of a package of about ₹32,611 crore**³**. Neither report I read says where the money will come from.

On 6 October the same cabinet decided to raise the price of milk by up to ₹8 a litre. It did not announce the decision. A Legislative Council poll was due on 23 October, and the announcement came on 29 October, two days after the results**¹¹ ¹²**. On 1 November a litre of toned milk went from ₹46 to ₹54**¹³**. On 5 November bus fares rose by 23% to 35%**¹⁹**.

I have not seen the note, the cabinet orders or the fare order. I rely on press reports that quote them, and I say so wherever it matters.

Three sets of people have held office in this story. The BJP governed Karnataka from July 2019 to May 2023, under B.S. Yediyurappa and then Basavaraj Bommai. The Congress has governed since May 2023, under Siddaramaiah and, since 3 June 2026, under D.K. Shivakumar, who also holds the finance portfolio. The National Democratic Alliance has governed the Union throughout.

The note and the litre of milk are the two ends of one question. A state that has promised more than it has must find the rest somewhere. It can borrow, it can leave bills unpaid, or it can let the people who buy milk and ride buses pay what the treasury does not. Karnataka has done all three. The question for this article is not whether a state may do these things. It may. The question is how it should do them, and what it owes the people while it does.

## Part One — What happened: a state that spent to the edge of the law

Karnataka's fiscal law sets three tests. The budget for 2026-27 passes two of them by a hair and fails the third.

| Test in the state's fiscal law | Limit | 2026-27 budget estimate |
|---|---|---|
| Fiscal deficit | 3% of the state's output | 2.95%, or ₹97,448 crore**¹ ⁴** |
| Total liabilities | 25% of the state's output | 24.94%, or ₹8,24,389 crore**¹ ⁴** |
| Revenue account | No deficit | A deficit of ₹22,957 crore**⁴** |
| Unpaid bills in four departments | Counted by no test | ₹36,136 crore, by the finance department's note as reported**¹ ²** |

The third row is the one to watch. A revenue deficit means the state borrows to meet its running costs, and not only to build. The state has run one in every year since 2023-24. It was ₹9,272 crore in that year and ₹20,834 crore in 2024-25, by the audited accounts**⁵**. The government's own plan expects a surplus again only by 2029-30**⁷**.

The fourth row is counted nowhere. The state keeps its accounts in cash. A bill counts as spending on the day it is paid, and not on the day the road is finished. So ₹36,136 crore of work already done appears in neither the deficit nor the debt. My arithmetic: that sum is about 1.1% of the state's output. If those bills were paid this year by borrowing, the deficit would be about 4% and the debt about 26%. Both would be over the limit. That is my inference and not the auditor's finding. The contractors' association counts eight departments and puts the dues at about ₹38,000 crore**⁸**.

The cost of old borrowing has grown under every government. The auditor's table shows interest taking 9.59% of the state's revenue in 2015-16 and 14.53% in 2024-25**⁵**. In the 2026-27 budget, interest is ₹53,332 crore and the five guarantees are ₹51,286 crore**⁴**. The state now pays more to its lenders than it gives through its largest welfare programme.

<figure class="chart">
<figcaption><span class="fig-no">Figure 1</span><strong>Interest took under 10 paise of each rupee of revenue in 2015-16 and over 14 paise in 2024-25</strong><span>Interest payments, per cent of revenue receipts. Grey: before the BJP government of July 2019. Light blue: years under the BJP government. Dark blue: years under the Congress government since May 2023.</span></figcaption>
<div class="bars dbt-cols" style="--max:14.9">
<div class="bar dbt-gr"><span class="l">2015-16</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:9.6"></i><b>9.6</b></span></div>
<div class="bar dbt-gr"><span class="l">2016-17</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:9.7"></i><b>9.7</b></span></div>
<div class="bar dbt-gr"><span class="l">2017-18</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:10.2"></i><b>10.2</b></span></div>
<div class="bar dbt-gr"><span class="l">2018-19</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:10.1"></i><b>10.1</b></span></div>
<div class="bar dbt-lt"><span class="l">2019-20</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:11.3"></i><b>11.3</b></span></div>
<div class="bar dbt-lt"><span class="l">2020-21</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:14.9"></i><b>14.9</b></span></div>
<div class="bar dbt-lt"><span class="l">2021-22</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:13.4"></i><b>13.4</b></span></div>
<div class="bar dbt-lt"><span class="l">2022-23</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:12.9"></i><b>12.9</b></span></div>
<div class="bar dbt-dk"><span class="l">2023-24</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:13.7"></i><b>13.7</b></span></div>
<div class="bar dbt-dk"><span class="l">2024-25</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:14.5"></i><b>14.5</b></span></div>
</div>
<small>Source: CAG State Finances report 2024-25.</small>
</figure>

The government has a real defence, and it should be heard in its best form. The state passes the two tests that the law treats as binding. Its liabilities are below the average for all states, which the auditor put at 27.63% of output in 2024-25**⁵**. It raises about three of every four rupees of its revenue itself**⁴**. The guarantees put about ₹50,000 crore a year into households, more than half of it as a monthly payment to women. An elected government may choose that. And the Union cut the state's share of central taxes from 4.713% to 3.647% for five years, before the next Finance Commission raised it to 4.131%**⁴**.

<figure class="chart">
<figcaption><span class="fig-no">Figure 2</span><strong>Karnataka's liabilities are below the all-state level, and well below Tamil Nadu, Kerala and Punjab</strong><span>Outstanding liabilities, per cent of GSDP, 2024-25 budget estimates as counted by PRS. Orange line: all states, 27.5%. The basis differs from the auditor's, so Karnataka's 26% here is not the 23.73% of the audit.</span></figcaption>
<div class="dbt-key"><i></i>All states: 27.5%</div>
<div class="bars dbt-bars dbt-in" style="--max:46">
<div class="bar"><span class="l">Gujarat</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:17"></i><b>17%</b><span class="dbt-mk" style="--at:27.5"></span></span></div>
<div class="bar"><span class="l">Maharashtra</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:18"></i><b>18%</b><span class="dbt-mk" style="--at:27.5"></span></span></div>
<div class="bar hi"><span class="l">Karnataka</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:26"></i><b>26%</b><span class="dbt-mk" style="--at:27.5"></span></span></div>
<div class="bar"><span class="l">Telangana</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:26"></i><b>26%</b><span class="dbt-mk" style="--at:27.5"></span></span></div>
<div class="bar"><span class="l">Tamil Nadu</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:30"></i><b>30%</b><span class="dbt-mk" style="--at:27.5"></span></span></div>
<div class="bar"><span class="l">Andhra Pradesh</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:33"></i><b>33%</b><span class="dbt-mk" style="--at:27.5"></span></span></div>
<div class="bar"><span class="l">Kerala</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:36"></i><b>36%</b><span class="dbt-mk" style="--at:27.5"></span></span></div>
<div class="bar"><span class="l">Punjab</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:46"></i><b>46%</b><span class="dbt-mk" style="--at:27.5"></span></span></div>
</div>
<small>Source: PRS Legislative Research, State of State Finances, October 2025.</small>
</figure>

The auditor accepts part of that defence and not all of it. Its report for 2024-25 says the debt stayed within 25% but that it was "too early to opine that debt burden of the State has reached a sustainable level". On the guarantees it writes: "The introduction of five guarantee schemes in 2023-24 shifted the State from a Revenue Surplus to Revenue Deficit." It adds that the state "was forced to apply a squeeze on some of its ongoing schemes such as on Nutrition"**⁵ ⁶**. Those are the auditor's words. I add none of my own to them.

## Part Two — What happened next: six prices, raised by order

A state at the edge of its limits has one more place to turn, which is the price list. Between June 2024 and November 2026 six prices and taxes rose in Karnataka.

| What rose | By how much | Who decided | When |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fuel tax | About ₹3 a litre on petrol and diesel, then about ₹2 more on diesel | The State government, by notification | 15 June 2024 and 1 April 2025**¹⁴ ¹⁶ ¹⁷** |
| Bus fares | 15%, then 23% to 35% | The State cabinet and its transport department | 5 January 2025 and 5 November 2026**¹⁸ ¹⁹** |
| Power bills | A pension surcharge of 36 paise a unit, falling to 34 paise | The regulator, on a direction first given by the State in 2021 | From 1 April 2025**²⁰** |
| Bengaluru water | 32% or more on the bill | The water board, with the State's approval | April 2025**³⁵** |
| Property registration fee | From 1% to 2% | The State government | 31 August 2025**³⁴** |
| Milk | ₹4 a litre, then ₹8 | The State cabinet | 1 April 2025 and 1 November 2026**¹² ³⁸** |

<figure class="chart">
<figcaption><span class="fig-no">Figure 3</span><strong>One household bill, six lines, and only one of them ends in the State treasury</strong><span>Each line of the bill, the body that decided it and where the money goes. Orange: the one line that reaches the treasury. The metro fare is included, though a committee under a central law fixed it.</span></figcaption>
<div class="dbt-order">
<div class="dbt-o"><b>1</b><strong>Milk</strong><span>Decided by: The State cabinet. Goes to: Dairy farmers, ₹7 of ₹8, and the milk co-operatives.</span></div>
<div class="dbt-o dbt-o-hi"><b>2</b><strong>Petrol and diesel tax</strong><span>Decided by: The State government, by notification. Goes to: The State treasury.</span></div>
<div class="dbt-o"><b>3</b><strong>Bus fares</strong><span>Decided by: The State cabinet and its transport department. Goes to: Four State bus corporations.</span></div>
<div class="dbt-o"><b>4</b><strong>Metro fares</strong><span>Decided by: A committee under a central law. Goes to: The metro company.</span></div>
<div class="dbt-o"><b>5</b><strong>Power bill additions</strong><span>Decided by: The regulator, after State decisions of 2021 and 2022. Goes to: Supply companies and pension funds.</span></div>
<div class="dbt-o"><b>6</b><strong>Bengaluru water</strong><span>Decided by: The water board, with the State's approval. Goes to: The water board.</span></div>
</div>
<small>Source: the reports cited in Part Two.</small>
</figure>

Only the fuel tax goes into the treasury. The other rises go to bodies the treasury would otherwise have to support: bus corporations it owes money to, pension funds it was liable for, and dairy farmers. The milk rise is the clearest case. In 2023 the Congress manifesto promised to raise the State's incentive to dairy farmers "from Rs.5 to Rs.7" a litre, and the BJP manifesto promised the same ₹7**²² ²³**. The incentive was still ₹5 when the cabinet briefed the press on 29 October 2026**¹²**. The farmer's extra income now comes from the buyer of milk, and not from the treasury that promised it.

Each rise came with a reason, and the reasons deserve a fair hearing. Of the ₹8 on milk, ₹7 is promised to the dairy farmer**¹²**. On fuel, the Chief Minister of the day said the rise "ensures we can fund essential public services and development projects"**¹⁵**. The bus corporations' diesel and wage costs had risen while fares stood still. The water board had not revised its rates for eleven years**³⁵**.

**Did the guarantees cause the rises?** No report I read says so, and the government denies it. That is not the same as proof that they did not. When fuel tax rose in June 2024, an official who was not named said it would bring ₹2,500 crore to ₹3,000 crore a year**¹⁴**. On the day bus fares rose, the transport minister said the State had paid its bus corporations about ₹16,596 crore for women's free travel and still owed them ₹6,360 crore**¹⁹**. A government that has budgeted about ₹51,000 crore a year for five schemes has less room to keep a fare frozen. I can say that much, and no more.

What I can say plainly is how the rises were made. On the reports I read, not one of the six was put to a vote in the Legislature. A tax needs a law, and Article 265 of the Constitution says so: "No tax shall be levied or collected except by authority of law."**²⁴** But the rate of a tax can be changed by a government notification under that law, and both fuel tax rises were made that way**¹⁶ ¹⁷**. A fare and a water rate are changed by an order. The citizen learned of each rise from a press briefing.

The cost does not fall evenly. I worked out the added monthly cost for two Bengaluru households on three items only: milk, the city bus and the additions to the power bill. It is an illustration and not a survey.

<figure class="chart">
<figcaption><span class="fig-no">Figure 4</span><strong>One household pays about ₹448 more and receives ₹2,000. The other pays about ₹1,033 more and receives nothing</strong><span>Two invented Bengaluru households, rupees a month, on three items only: milk, the city bus and the additions to the power bill. The first is on Gruha Lakshmi and Gruha Jyothi, and its free power keeps it out of the power additions. Orange: what each receives. An illustration, not a survey.</span></figcaption>
<div class="bars" style="--max:2000">
<div class="bar"><span class="l">On the guarantees: pays more</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:448"></i><b>₹448</b></span></div>
<div class="bar hi"><span class="l">On the guarantees: receives</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:2000"></i><b>₹2,000</b></span></div>
<div class="bar"><span class="l">Outside them: pays more</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:1033"></i><b>₹1,033</b></span></div>
<div class="bar hi"><span class="l">Outside them: receives</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:0"></i><b>₹0</b></span></div>
</div>
<small>Source: the author's arithmetic from the prices reported.</small>
</figure>

## Part Three — What it should have been: five old rules for a treasury

None of this is a new problem. Rulers have always needed more than they had, and thinkers in every century have told them how to take it. I use five rules. Four are quoted from their sources. The fourth in the list is my own.

### Take little, and by degrees

The best-known Indian rule on taxation is a verse in the Manusmṛti**²⁵**.

> *yathālpālpam adantyādyaṃ vāryokovatsaṣaṭpadāḥ*
> *tathālpālpo grahītavyo rāṣṭrād rājñābdikaḥ karaḥ*
>
> As the leech, the calf and the bee take their food little by little, so the king should take the yearly tax from the realm little by little.
>
> Manusmṛti 7.129. The English is my rendering, after the translation cited.

The bee is the image that has lasted. It takes what the flower can spare, it comes back often, and the flower is still there next season. The rule is about the size of each demand and about its rhythm.

Karnataka did the opposite, and both governments had a hand in it. City bus fares were last revised in 2014 and other bus fares in 2020, and the water board's rates in 2014**¹⁸ ³⁵**. The property registration fee had not moved for 22 years. For years nothing was taken. Then fares rose by 15% in January 2025 and by up to 35% in November 2026. A fare held still while costs rise is a subsidy that nobody voted for and nobody counts. Somebody has to end it, and the one who ends it does so in a single blow. The freeze was not kindness and the jump was not courage. Neither is the bee's way.

<figure class="chart">
<figcaption><span class="fig-no">Figure 5</span><strong>Five charges had not moved for 5 to 22 years when they were raised in 2025</strong><span>Years between the last revision of each charge and its rise in 2025. The freezes run through Congress, coalition and BJP governments.</span></figcaption>
<div class="bars" style="--max:22">
<div class="bar hi"><span class="l">Property registration fee</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:22"></i><b>22 years</b></span></div>
<div class="bar"><span class="l">Bengaluru city bus fare</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:11"></i><b>11 years</b></span></div>
<div class="bar"><span class="l">Bengaluru water rates</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:11"></i><b>11 years</b></span></div>
<div class="bar"><span class="l">Namma Metro fare</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:8"></i><b>8 years</b></span></div>
<div class="bar"><span class="l">Bus fare outside Bengaluru</span><span class="track"><i style="--v:5"></i><b>5 years</b></span></div>
</div>
<small>Source: the reports cited in this article. The count of years is the author's.</small>
</figure>

Ibn Khaldun, writing in North Africa in 1377, saw where the other road leads. "It should be known that at the beginning of a dynasty, taxation yields a large revenue from small assessments. At the end of the dynasty, taxation yields a small revenue from large assessments."**²⁸** His reason was that a state's expenses grow with its habits, each new demand is laid on top of the last, and in the end the people who pay lose the will to produce. I do not say Karnataka is there. Its economy grows fast. I say the direction of the last two years is the one he described.

### Take in the open

Adam Smith's second rule for any tax is certainty. "The tax which each individual is bound to pay ought to be certain, and not arbitrary. The time of payment, the manner of payment, the quantity to be paid, ought all to be clear and plain to the contributor, and to every other person."**²⁹**

Measure the milk decision against that sentence. The cabinet decided on 6 October and announced on 29 October, after a poll**¹¹ ¹²**. For twenty-three days the government knew what every household would pay from 1 November, and the households did not. The government's reason was the election code. That is a reason for not announcing a benefit. It is a weak reason for hiding a cost.

Tiruvaḷḷuvar is harsher than Smith about a ruler who demands without a plain right**²⁷**.

> A scepter-wielding king requesting a gift is like a lance-bearing robber demanding, "Give me all you have."
>
> Tirukkuṟaḷ 552, in the Himalayan Academy translation

I do not call any of these rises robbery. Each had a law or an order behind it. I quote the couplet for its test, which is the right one: when the man with the sceptre asks, can the citizen refuse, and was he told why? A price changed by order, announced after a vote, fails the second half of that test.

### Guard the treasury before you promise

Kauṭilya opens his chapter on the treasury with three words**²⁶**.

> *kośapūrvāḥ sarvārambhāḥ*
>
> All undertakings depend first on the treasury.
>
> Arthaśāstra 2.8.1. The English is my rendering.

The treasury comes first, and the undertaking second. In 2023 Karnataka's parties reversed the order. The Congress manifesto sets out the five guarantees on pages 6 and 25. I found no cost beside them and no statement of how they would be paid for**²²**. The BJP manifesto prints ₹30,000 crore for an agriculture fund on page 12, with no period and no source of money**²³**. The first costing a voter could read came after the election, in the budget of July 2023.

The same fault shows in public works, and here the BJP government is charged by its successor. In July 2023 Siddaramaiah told the Assembly that the water resources department had "approved works five times its allocation"**⁹**. Finance department sources put works in three departments at ₹1.40 lakh crore, much of it tendered in the six months before the election**¹⁰**. The first is the statement of an interested party. The present government then did the same thing in the open: it approved a road scheme the day after its own finance department advised against it.

### Do not hide what you owe

This rule is mine. I take it from the two words at the head of this series. If truth is to triumph, the first place it must be told is the ledger.

Karnataka's ledger does not tell it. The ₹36,136 crore of unpaid bills is real money owed for real work, and it appears in no deficit and no debt figure. The auditor's own count of dues not paid is far smaller, because it counts only what it can verify. So the public has two legal ratios that say the state is safe, and one leaked note that says it has run out of room. A contractor who is not paid cannot pay his labourers. They have no claim on the state at all.

The same habit shows in the power bill. In 2021 the BJP government directed that the government's own share of pensions for retired power staff be collected from consumers. The regulator refused twice. After a High Court ruling, it allowed the charge in March 2025, under the Congress government, to recover ₹4,659 crore over three years**²⁰**. One government moved its own debt onto the consumer's bill. The next one collects it.

<figure class="chart">
<figcaption><span class="fig-no">Figure 6</span><strong>The order in which the state pays, as the dates in this article show it</strong><span>From the group paid soonest to the group paid last. The order is the author's reading, not a finding of the auditor.</span></figcaption>
<div class="dbt-order">
<div class="dbt-o"><b>1</b><strong>Lenders</strong><span>Interest and principal on the due date. No missed payment reported.</span></div>
<div class="dbt-o"><b>2</b><strong>Employees and pensioners</strong><span>Each month. Pay raised by 27.5% from August 2024.</span></div>
<div class="dbt-o dbt-o-lt"><b>3</b><strong>Households on the guarantee lists</strong><span>Paid, with some months late or missing.</span></div>
<div class="dbt-o dbt-o-hi"><b>4</b><strong>Contractors</strong><span>Bills pending since 2021-22, by their account. ₹36,136 crore in four departments.</span></div>
<div class="dbt-o dbt-o-hi"><b>5</b><strong>Labourers</strong><span>No direct claim on the state for the contractor's bill. No count of wages owed.</span></div>
</div>
<small>Source: reports and audit cited in the article.</small>
</figure>

### Do not send the bill to the unborn

The opposing view deserves its best words first. Indian philosophy preserves it in a verse that the critics of the Cārvāka school attributed to it**³⁰**.

> While life remains let a man live happily, let him feed on ghee even though he runs in debt.
> When once the body becomes ashes, how can it ever return again?
>
> Sarva-darśana-saṅgraha, chapter 1, in E.B. Cowell's translation

It is quoted as a taunt, and it has a serious form. A woman who cannot feed her children this month is not helped by a balanced budget in 2030. Borrowing for her is not ghee. I accept that. A state may borrow for the poor who are alive today, as it borrows for a road.

The answer is about who repays. In 1789 Thomas Jefferson wrote to James Madison "that the earth belongs in usufruct to the living", and concluded that "no generation can contract debts greater than may be paid during the course of it's own existence"**³¹**. Usufruct is the right to use a thing without using it up. A loan for a canal leaves the canal to the people who repay it. A loan for this year's running costs leaves them only the interest.

That is the meaning of the third legal test, and Karnataka has failed it since 2023-24. The children who will service these loans cannot be asked. They are the first people this debate leaves out.

## Part Four — The gap, and who owns it

The same five rules, put to each government. The rises in liabilities are my subtraction from the auditor's figures.

| The rule | BJP government, 2019 to 2023 | Congress government, 2023 to date |
|---|---|---|
| Take little, and by degrees | Raised bus fares once, by 12%, outside Bengaluru. Left city bus fares and water rates frozen. Cut fuel prices by about ₹7 in 2021**¹⁴ ²¹** | Ended the freezes with rises of 15% to 35%. Set yearly rules for water rates and a committee for bus fares**¹⁸ ¹⁹ ³⁵** |
| Take in the open | Gave reasons. I found no decision held back | Gave reasons each time. Held the milk decision for 23 days. Raised fuel tax eleven days after the Lok Sabha results**¹¹ ¹² ¹⁴** |
| Guard the treasury before you promise | Charged by its successor with approving works five times the allocation**⁹** | Made five guarantees with no published cost. Approved roads against its finance department's advice**¹ ³** |
| Do not hide what you owe | Directed its own pension liability onto power bills. Left unpaid bills that no audit has split**²⁰** | Counts ₹36,136 crore of unpaid bills outside every limit. Owed its bus corporations ₹6,360 crore on the day fares rose**¹ ¹⁹** |
| Do not send the bill to the unborn | Liabilities rose by about ₹1.37 lakh crore from March 2021 to March 2023. Its last full year was the best in the auditor's series**⁵** | Liabilities rose by about ₹1.39 lakh crore from March 2023 to March 2025. A revenue deficit in every year**⁵** |

The Congress government owns the largest single decision. It added a recurring cost of about ₹50,000 crore a year without costing it before the vote, and it has borrowed to meet running costs ever since. What it delivered is also the largest: a monthly payment to women who head households, on a scale few states have tried. It then went to the price list, and it did so by order.

The BJP government owns the habits that came before. On debt its record is better: its last full year, 2022-23, is the best in the auditor's five-year table, and it cut fuel prices in 2021. But the debt grew by almost the same sum in its last two years as in the next two. It released ₹5,282 crore, ₹8,489 crore and ₹10,949 crore by executive order before the legislature approved it, in three successive years, and its successor released ₹4,851 crore and ₹10,035 crore in the same way**⁵**. It left fares and water rates frozen for someone else to raise. And it was the first to move a liability of its own onto a consumer's bill.

The Union government owns one thing in this story. It accepted a Finance Commission award that cut Karnataka's share of central taxes by nearly a quarter for five years. The cut fell first on a BJP government in the state. The rupees still rose each year, and the next award restored about half of the lost share**⁴ ³³**.

My judgement, by the five rules, is that neither party can teach the other. The Congress broke the third rule more deeply, because a promise of ₹50,000 crore a year with no costing is larger than anything before it. The BJP broke the fourth rule first. On the second, the open hand, the present government's record is worse, and I have found no decision of the earlier one that was held back until a vote was over. I may have missed one.

## Part Five — The lesson: what a future finance minister can keep

Each failure has a repair. None needs new money. Each needs a government willing to be seen. The repairs are my proposals.

| The rule broken | The repair, as I propose it | Who can act | Where it has been done | How it can fail |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Take little, and by degrees | Revise every fare and tariff once a year by a published formula, capped | Cabinet and each board | Bengaluru's water board adopted 3% a year in 2025**³⁵** | A government skips a year before an election |
| Take in the open | Announce every price decision on the day it is taken, with the reason and the sum expected | Cabinet, by its own rule | No example found | An election code is cited as a reason to wait |
| Guard the treasury | Cost every manifesto promise before the vote, by an independent office | Election Commission and the Legislature | The Election Commission proposed disclosure in 2022, and a review committee proposed a fiscal council for the Union in 2017**³² ³⁷** | Parties objected then and may again |
| Do not hide what you owe | Publish a register of unpaid bills each month, beside the deficit | Finance department, by order | The department already holds the figure, as its note shows | Bills are kept off the register by not accepting them |
| Do not hide what you owe | Pay accepted bills within a fixed number of days, with interest after that | Legislature, by an Act | The MSMED Act, 2006, sets 45 days for small suppliers**³⁶** | A department delays accepting the work |
| Do not send the bill to the unborn | A dated path back to revenue balance, reported every quarter | Cabinet | The state's plan names 2029-30**⁷** | A date four years away binds no one in office today |

If you are twenty today, you may be in the Legislature in 2046, or in the finance department, or simply a voter with a manifesto in your hand. The lesson of these years is small enough to remember. When a party promises you something, ask what it costs and who pays. When a government raises a price, ask when it decided. When it says the books are within the law, ask what the books leave out. None of these questions needs an economist. Each one is what the old texts asked of a king.

## Ending — The note is still on the file

The finance department's note of 17 September 2026 is still on its file, and I still have not read it. The milk that cost ₹46 on 31 October costs ₹54 today. Between those two facts lies everything this article has tried to show: a state that promised before it counted, spent to the edge of its own law, kept its largest debt off its books, and then took from the buyer of milk without telling her when it had decided to.

The bee in Manu's verse takes little, comes often and hides nothing, because the flower can see it. The question I cannot answer is the one that matters most. In May 2023, would the voters of Karnataka have chosen the five guarantees if the price list of 2026 had been printed beside them? They might well have. Nobody gave them the chance to say.

## Words to keep

- A ruler may take what the people can bear, must say what he takes it for, and must not hide what he owes.
- A fare held still while costs rise is a subsidy that nobody voted for.
- The treasury comes first, and the undertaking second.
- A loan for a canal leaves the canal. A loan for running costs leaves only the interest.
- Ask what it costs, ask when they decided, ask what the books leave out.

## Sources

1. "Finance department flags fiscal squeeze as Karnataka weighs new projects", The Week, 22 September 2026. https://www.theweek.in/news/biz-tech/2026/09/22/finance-department-flags-fiscal-squeeze-as-karnataka-weighs-new-projects.html
2. "Karnataka finance dept cautions against new major projects amid fiscal constraints", PTI in ThePrint, 22 September 2026. https://theprint.in/india/karnataka-finance-dept-cautions-against-new-major-projects-amid-fiscal-constraints/3050205/
3. "Major infrastructure, tourism and fisheries projects get cabinet nod", Deccan Chronicle, 18 September 2026. https://www.deccanchronicle.com/amp/southern-states/karnataka/major-infrastructure-tourism-and-fisheries-projects-get-cabinet-nod-1988651
4. "Karnataka Budget Analysis 2026-27", PRS Legislative Research, March 2026. https://prsindia.org/budgets/states/karnataka-budget-analysis-2026-27
5. "Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India on State Finances for the year 2024-25, Government of Karnataka (Report No. 2 of 2026)", tabled 26 March 2026. https://cag.gov.in/ag2/karnataka/en/audit-report/details/124514
6. "Karnataka forced to cut down its funds for nutrition, local bodies due to increase in subsidies: CAG", PTI in ThePrint, 26 March 2026. https://theprint.in/india/ktaka-forced-to-cut-down-its-funds-fur-nutrition-local-bodies-due-to-increasing-in-subsidies-cag/2889749
7. "Rich state, borrowed money: Karnataka's growth story has a debt problem that is only getting worse", ThePrint, 14 March 2026. https://theprint.in/economy/rich-state-borrowed-money-karnatakas-growth-story-has-a-debt-problem-that-is-only-getting-worse/2878248
8. "KSCA threatens agitation over Rs 38,000 cr dues, alleges commission is higher now", PTI in ThePrint, 30 September 2026. https://theprint.in/india/ksca-threatens-agitation-over-rs-38000-cr-dues-alleges-commission-is-higher-now/3058091/
9. "Karnataka Budget: Rs 1 lakh crore needed to implement approved irrigation projects", Deccan Herald, July 2023. https://www.deccanherald.com/india/karnataka/karnataka-budget-rs-1-lakh-crore-needed-to-implement-approved-irrigation-projects-1235052.html
10. "Amid guarantee push, Karnataka government under pressure to keep projects afloat", Deccan Herald, 12 August 2023. https://www.deccanherald.com/amp/story/india%2Fkarnataka%2Famid-guarantee-push-karnataka-government-under-pressure-to-keep-projects-afloat-2645004
11. "Nandini milk may cost up to Rs 8 more per litre from November 1", The News Minute, 7 October 2026. https://www.thenewsminute.com/amp/story/karnataka/nandini-milk-may-cost-up-to-rs-8-more-per-litre-from-november-1
12. "Karnataka Cabinet clears Rs 8 per litre hike in Nandini milk price, farmers to get Rs 42 plus incentives from 1 November", The South First, 30 October 2026. https://thesouthfirst.com/karnataka/karnataka-cabinet-clears-rs-8-per-litre-hike-in-nandini-milk-price-farmers-to-get-rs-42-plus-incentives-from-1-november/
13. "Nandini Milk Price Hike From November 1: Karnataka Milk Prices Rise By Rs 8-12 Per Litre", GoodReturns, 1 November 2026. https://www.goodreturns.in/news/nandini-milk-price-hike-from-november-1-karnataka-milk-prices-rise-by-rs-8-12-per-litre-check-new-1544551.html
14. "Cash-strapped Karnataka hikes fuel tax by Rs 3/l, could earn Rs 2,500-3,000 cr more per yr", ThePrint, 15 June 2024. https://theprint.in/economy/cash-strapped-karnataka-hikes-fuel-tax-by-rs-3-l-could-earn-rs-2500-3000-cr-more-per-yr/2133115
15. "Hike in fuel prices will ensure funding essential services: CM Siddaramaiah", Business Standard, 16 June 2024. https://www.business-standard.com/india-news/hike-in-fuel-prices-will-ensure-funding-essential-services-cm-siddaramaiah-124061600327_1.html
16. "Diesel price hiked by Rs 2 per litre as Karnataka increases sales tax", The South First, 1 April 2025. https://thesouthfirst.com/karnataka/diesel-price-hiked-by-rs-2-per-litre-as-karnataka-increases-sales-tax
17. "Diesel prices to go up by Rs 2 per litre in Karnataka as Siddaramaiah Congress govt increases sales tax", India TV, 1 April 2025. https://www.indiatvnews.com/karnataka/diesel-prices-to-go-up-by-rs-2-per-litre-in-karnataka-as-siddaramaiah-congress-govt-increases-sales-tax-details-latest-updates-2025-04-01-983408
18. "Karnataka govt announces 15% hike in bus fares", The Week, 2 January 2025. https://www.theweek.in/news/india/2025/01/02/karnataka-govt-announces-15-hike-in-bus-fares.html
19. "Karnataka hikes bus fares by 23 to 35% across four state-run transport corporations from 5 November", The South First, 4 November 2026. https://thesouthfirst.com/karnataka/karnataka-hikes-bus-fares-by-23-to-35-across-four-state-run-transport-corporations-from-5-november/
20. "Karnataka power tariff to rise by 36 paise/unit from April 1", Deccan Herald, March 2025. https://www.deccanherald.com/india/karnataka/karnataka-power-tariff-to-rise-by-36-paiseunit-from-april-1-3455029
21. "KSRTC bus tickets to cost 12% more from February 26", Deccan Herald, February 2020. https://www.deccanherald.com/india/karnataka/ksrtc-bus-tickets-to-cost-12-more-from-february-26-808149.html
22. "Assembly Election Karnataka, Manifesto 2023: Sarva Janangada Shanthiya Thota", Karnataka Pradesh Congress Committee, 2023. 25-page edition. Pages 6, 10 and 25 are cited.
23. Bharatiya Janata Party, Karnataka Assembly election manifesto 2023 (English). 48 pages. Printed page 12 and PDF page 16 are cited.
24. Constitution of India, Article 265. https://www.constitutionofindia.net/articles/article-265-taxes-not-to-be-imposed-save-by-authority-of-law/
25. Manusmṛti 7.129, Sanskrit text with English translation, Enjoy Learning Sanskrit. https://enjoylearningsanskrit.com/scriptures/manu-smriti/chapter-7/verse-129
26. Kauṭilya, Arthaśāstra 2.8.1, Sanskrit text with English translation, Vedapath. https://vedapath.app/en/arthashastra/adhyakshaprachara/8
27. Tirukkuṟaḷ 552, in chapter 56, English translation published by Himalayan Academy. https://www.himalayanacademy.com/media/books/tirukural/web/pg_249.html
28. Ibn Khaldun, The Muqaddimah, chapter 3, section 36, translated by Franz Rosenthal (Princeton University Press), as quoted by Joshua Charles, 27 March 2019. https://joshuatcharles.squarespace.com/blog/2019/3/27/medieval-muslim-historian-low-taxes-help-build-high-taxes-destroy-civilization
29. Adam Smith, An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations (1776), Book V, chapter 2, part 2. https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/smith-adam/works/wealth-of-nations/book05/ch02b.htm
30. Mādhava, Sarva-darśana-saṅgraha, chapter 1, "The Cārvāka System", translated by E.B. Cowell. https://www.wisdomlib.org/hinduism/book/the-sarva-dar%C5%9Bana-sa%E1%B9%83graha/d/doc79745.html
31. Thomas Jefferson to James Madison, 6 September 1789. Founders Online, United States National Archives. https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Madison/01-12-02-0248
32. "Political parties should give details of how they plan to finance poll promises, proposes EC", Scroll, 4 October 2022. https://scroll.in/latest/1034284/scroll_in
33. "NDA-ruled Andhra Pradesh gains most among southern states under new tax devolution formula", South First, 1 February 2026. https://thesouthfirst.com/andhrapradesh/nda-ruled-andhra-pradesh-gains-most-among-southern-states-under-new-tax-devolution-formula
34. "Property deals to cost more, registration fee hiked to 2%", Deccan Herald, 30 August 2025. https://www.deccanherald.com/amp/story/india%2Fkarnataka%2Fproperty-deals-to-cost-more-registration-fee-hiked-to-2-2-3704857
35. "Bengalureans will now have to shell more for water bills, rates revised after 11 yrs", Deccan Herald, 10 April 2025. https://www.deccanherald.com/amp/story/india%2Fkarnataka%2Fbengaluru%2Fbengalureans-will-now-have-to-shell-more-for-water-bills-rates-revised-after-11-yrs-3486983
36. "The Stringency Of Interest Provisions Under MSMED Act: Implementation And Judicial Interpretation", LiveLaw, on sections 15 and 16 of the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006. https://www.livelaw.in/amp/law-firms/law-firm-articles-/the-stringency-of-interest-provisions-under-msmed-act-implementation-and
37. "FRBM Review Committee Report Summary", PRS Legislative Research, 2017. https://prsindia.org/files/policy/policy_committee_reports/1493207354_FRBM%20Review%20Committee%20Report%20Summary.pdf

38. "Karnataka government approves ₹4 per litre milk price hike, details awaited on distribution", The South First, 27 March 2025. https://thesouthfirst.com/news/karnataka-government-approves-%e2%82%b94-per-litre-milk-price-hike-details-awaited-on-distribution/

## How I wrote this

**What I read in the original.** The Comptroller and Auditor General's report on Karnataka's State Finances for 2024-25, for the series on liabilities, interest, the revenue account and releases by executive order, and for its words on the guarantees. The PRS Legislative Research analysis of the 2026-27 budget. The 2023 manifestos of the Congress and the BJP. Article 265 of the Constitution. Jefferson's letter to Madison. Adam Smith's chapter on taxes.

**What rests on press reports.** The finance department's note of 17 September 2026, which I know from two reports that quote it. Every price and tax decision in Part Two. The cabinet decisions on roads and on milk. The transport minister's figures for what the State paid and owed its bus corporations. The history of the pension surcharge. I have read none of the orders themselves.

**What I have not seen or could not confirm.** The note itself. What the ₹36,136 crore consists of. Any audited split of unpaid bills between the two governments. Whether dairy farmers have received the higher price since 1 November 2026. Any official statement that links a price rise to the cost of the guarantees. The official list of fares and rates before each rise.

**Quotations.** The Manusmṛti and Arthaśāstra verses are quoted from online editions that print the Sanskrit, and the English of both is my rendering. I checked each against one edition only. The Tirukkuṟaḷ couplet and the Cārvāka verse are in published translations, named beside them. The Ibn Khaldun sentences are Franz Rosenthal's translation as quoted by a secondary source. I have not checked them against the printed book.

**Readings that are mine.** The five rules as a set, and the fourth rule itself. The use of Tirukkuṟaḷ 552, which speaks of a king who asks for gifts, as a test for a price raised by order. The judgement in Part Four of which government broke which rule more. The two household examples. All arithmetic marked as mine.

**How the same test was applied to others.** The five rules were put to the BJP government of 2019 to 2023 and to the Congress government since 2023, from the same audit table where one exists. Where the BJP years are thinner in my evidence, as on the timing of announcements, I have said so. The Union government was tested on the one decision that bears on this subject, the state's share of central taxes.

**What I did not do.** I did not interview a farmer, a commuter, a contractor or an official. I did not send questions to the finance department. I did not test whether the guarantees changed the lives of the women who receive them, which is the subject of another article.