# The Philosophy of Everything — Part I: On Epistemology, Chapter 4: Rationality

By Nithin Palal · 30 November 2022 · 12 min read
Section: Philosophy · Series: The Philosophy of Everything
Source: https://nithinpalal.com/books/the-philosophy-of-everything/chapter-4-rationality

> In this chapter, we examine the scope of rationality. We need to know what rationale implies through a more objective approach.
*In this chapter, we examine the scope of rationality. We need to know what rationale implies through a more objective approach. A person with false assumptions will indulge in junk reasoning. So, it is critical to understand common fallacies to prevent them. Various forms of reasoning through scepticism allow people to flourish in a world of incorrect information without hurting any other creation.*

The topics we cover here are:

- Rationality

Types of Rationality

- Logical Reasoning (Deductive, Inductive and Abductive)
- Common Fallacies

In this technological world, arriving at the correct meaning has become critical to the existence of an individual. If these meanings are valid after conducting a thorough process of verification, it is rational. If not, it is irrational.

People fraternize with others of similar beliefs to gain acceptance of the meanings they derive. Unfortunately, irrationality often leads to blind faith. As more people join, this blind faith gives the illusion of being rational. Such belief systems can dominate the world, irrespective of right or wrong.

When they realize the invalidity of their beliefs, some people change their understanding. If they do not, they keep running into more trouble until life punishes them and forces them to make the necessary corrections. As long as a person does not run into trouble, they stick to their beliefs. Only highly conscious people foresee a problem and make the necessary corrections. Such people can also learn from other people’s mistakes before letting them happen to themselves.

Evolution favours people who are more rational because they quickly adapt to the changes in their circumstances. We must, therefore, be non-possessive of our beliefs and always be ready to accommodate newer valid concepts. Life rewards such flexibility by enhancing survival through a multitude of choices. On the other hand, most irrational people remain stuck to their beliefs. They will wait indefinitely for the circumstances to favour them once again.

Adjusting to life requires the cultivation of new habits. Our brains are flexible enough to achieve whatever we intend to attain by modifying our habits to suit our goals.

Suppose we believe that it is in our nature to achieve objectives. We must examine our memories for evidence to support them. Having found out that we have always finished our tasks in the past, we can be sure that our belief about ourselves is correct.

There is no need to panic if we never complete tasks and leave them midway. It proves that we are wrong about ourselves. We may condition our brains to do what we want by taking pleasure in them. In this case, we end up with a new achiever brain by finishing simple tasks and believing it enhances our survival.

Similarly, it is in the self-interest of all fraternities in a culture that they must be objectively rational and not favour or be against any conclusions.

“Rationality” is the capacity to think rightly, speak sensibly and act responsibly in the best interest of increasing the chances of survival without harming the concerns of others.

Subjective rational functions through the prism of an individual’s mental modification. A person committing suicide considers ending life in their best interest. However, the truth is that they are unable to employ knowledge rationally. They are, unfortunately, incapable of converting misfortune into fortune due to a lack of understanding of the nature of reality.

After monitoring the blood pressure of a million people, scientists set the normal range between 90/60 mm Hg and 120/80 mm Hg. Likewise, we can arrive at plausible objective conclusions about various realities by adding different subjectivities. Otherwise, it is impossible to quantify rationality, as it differs from person to person.

Let us analyze how people respond to a child in danger when there is no personal threat to them. Multiple reactions are possible to the same situation. Some may save the child, while another may be indifferent.

From the survey of thousands of people, we can arrive at an acceptable response that is objective. The goal is to find the best plausible outcome. If the majority saves the child, we conclude that this behaviour is the ideal response. A person who responds by rescuing an unknown child in danger is acting rationally. Likewise, we can conclude that saving a child whose life is under threat is rational. Anyone who does not rescue the child is acting irrationally.

Objective rationality has its complications. The majority may not act rationally often, as we see in the issue of climate change. It is because people often do not understand and recognize changes happening gradually over a long period. Such small changes escape their intelligence and fail to come within the purview of their consciousness. The inability of Europeans to comprehend that the earth orbits the sun until the sixteenth century C.E. is another case where the majority refuses to acknowledge a rational fact.

Our planet has been orbiting the sun for two thousand and seventy-eight years or more in India. In 57 B.C.E., after several thousand years, the Indians replaced a solar calendar with a more accurate lunisolar one. Indians continue to use it despite scientific advancements because of its higher precision than the Gregorian calendar that is officially in use. Unfortunately, it takes time for the majority to accept rationality. Such delays almost certainly hinder the progress of our civilization.

Let us explore some of the ways to reason.

## Logical Reasoning

“Reasoning” is the ability to solve a problem using logic based on new or old information. It applies scepticism to the process of knowing. Furthermore, it allows us to weigh the pros and cons of our choices. As a result, we may choose the right one in our best interest during uncertain times.

There are several types of reasoning. In this book, we shall cover only three of them, namely deductive, inductive, and abductive reasoning.

### Deductive Reasoning

A “deduction” is when we conclude from widely accepted facts like “we are human” and “all humans are mortal”. Therefore, the conclusion that we are mortal must be correct.

A deduction will always be valid only if the premises hold. Hence, it is pretty complicated to use them daily, as a conclusive generalization of any statement is difficult and uncommon. An age-old problem with this type of logic is that it leaves little or no room to derive new findings from their premises.

Before we travel to a new country, we research to learn more about its culture. We deduce countless preconceptions, such as language, eating habits and lifestyle. Some of these deductions could be racist and fuel further divisions in society.

Deductive logic is a top-down approach to knowledge. This logic system provides the foundation of holistic philosophy, where Ayurveda and yoga are the product of such a thought process.

### Inductive Reasoning

In “induction”, we conclude the fire by observing the smoke.

Unlike in deduction, we generalize conclusions based on specific scenarios. It is a bottom-up approach to finding facts.

We use this logic in our daily lives, as it is easy. Looking at heavy traffic patterns, we may conclude that we will be late for work if we do not start early.

Modern medicine and science are the products of reductionist philosophy founded on this logic system.

The truth of the premises does not necessarily guarantee the conclusions and therefore, they are prone to many errors. We may conclude that the heavy traffic is due to an increasing number of cars coming onto the roads. However, the truth may be a faulty traffic system.

### Abductive Reasoning

The third type of reasoning is “abduction”, where we draw a probable conclusion. For example, if our child is silent, we know something is wrong.

Such findings are primarily false and require further verification. However, it helps us deal with uncertainties by letting us make the best guesses.

There are others beyond the scope of this book.

## Common Fallacies

As Malvika notes, Latika has vanilla ice cream three times a day and concludes that her colleague loves ice cream. However, the truth is that Latika lost a bet with her sister Radhika. She has to eat the ice cream she hates every day for a month and send a selfie as proof. There is always a possibility of error while rationalizing human behaviour. So, sometimes it is better to examine and learn through debates.

We apply reasoning mainly for situations in our lives. When understanding human behaviour, the conclusion can go wrong due to our irrational nature. There can be a fallacy in the premises and when we wrongly infer the correlation of ideas, like in weather forecasting. Such predictions involve the permutations and combinations of many causal relations. Not all of them may be causing a particular phenomenon.

Here are some general fallacies:

People often attribute an individual’s behaviour to the entire community. An error occurs when our prejudices, hypocrisies or personal emotions interfere. Unfortunately, we hastily conclude without reasoning to avoid thinking and expending energy. Faulty conclusions typically lead us to severe problems in the future. Hence, it is crucial to set aside our subjectivity and objectively approach reasoning.

Secondly, an error may occur in the relationship between the premises in the arguments. For example, if the fact and the reason for the assertion are not authentic. A fallacy arises when environmental activists blame oil consumers for global warming when several factors contribute to it. Usually, this type of fallacy originates when we attribute a single cause to an effect.

People can make a mistake when they think that god is real because there is no evidence against it. A lack of evidence does not establish any fact. Hence, falsifiability is paramount to reasoning.

Another fallacy emerges due to the dual nature of reality. Imagine ending up in a courtroom where a person is on trial for a crime. A guilty or not guilty verdict may not provide the complete picture. Lovers sometimes face this crisis when their feelings for each other are unclear, which leads to a wrong decision. The world does not exist in black or white. The reality is often in between.

People frequently indulge in intellectual forecasting. Typically, we see an effect and conclude that a chain of events will follow. Such assumptions, lacking evidence to back up the outcomes, lead to fallacies. A skirmish at the border between two armies may lead to false media reports of war breaking out and other scenarios.

We live in a highly unpredictable, transitory world. Any “causal plane” currently unknown to us may interact and change the direction of our lives. We discuss it in a later chapter.

There are many common instances where our conclusion may only be another interpretation of our initial perception. When we hear a gunshot, we may make an incorrect understanding, thinking it came from the television.

Frequently in our lives, we face situations where we believe whatever is wrong will fix itself without our interference. It happens due to our tendency to outsource our decisions to a higher power or over-dependence on luck. After we realize that we made a mistake in our judgement, we do not endeavour to fix it. Instead, we think that it will somehow resolve itself. An individual hikes on the wrong path and realizes it midway. However, they continue, thinking they will reach their destination somehow.

A fallacy may occur when we conclude that an invalid testimony is authentic. It can be a simple miscommunication or misunderstanding. It could also be a deliberate attempt to confuse, deceive or mislead, resulting in invalid conclusions. While driving, we may follow the navigation and end up in a forest due to a glitch. Occasionally, a person may give false information to harm us.

Sometimes a collective fallacy occurs when a person after meeting with an accident lies in a pool of blood. Everyone assumes that the other person may help and downplays their responsibilities resulting in numerous losses of lives saved otherwise.

Of all the fallacies, the biggest is justifying our assumptions because the majority agree with them. Misleading people with irrational opinions is easy. All we have to do is make our explanation appear convincing to them. The tendency to remain ignorant is high among the general population. As we know, the majority view does not need to be correct. Despite plenty of evidence from different fields of knowledge, many do not believe in the theory of organic evolution. The trivial understanding that God created this world is more appealing than a fact validated multiple times through a proper scientific methodology.

Using logic is vital to the smooth functioning of society. There is a higher probability of creating issues in the community when we live without reason. Therefore, we must ensure that it is perfect without errors and identify those that deceive people.

A mistake can happen in any of the premises while reasoning. We must remove those we encounter daily by consciously avoiding them whenever they pop up in our awareness. This world, from the ground up, consists of ideas. We experience them differently depending upon our unique mental modifications. The simplest explanation is most likely the correct reasoning. We must ensure that rationality should always be the basis of all such changes because an error in it can harm our survival. If our foundation is wrong, the life we build on it crumbles. Our extinction will merely be a matter of time. Therefore, it is crucial to conclude without any fallacies.

Miseries are the consequences of ignorance. All problems originate due to the inability to use reason. Knowledge and learning to conclude observations properly can solve the majority of them. Hence, it is vital to remove the errors in the knowledge process. We must cultivate such habits of reasoning consciously in the beginning, and over time, after consistent practice, they become intuitive. However, the logic we use must be objective and its methods acceptable to all.

So, the next time we hear the following. A piece of apple mysteriously appears when a boy undergoes puberty to warn him against straying away from God. In addition, it is a punishment for disobeying God and eating from the tree of knowledge. When we hear such beliefs, we should cultivate a habit of not taking them seriously if they are not verifiable. If there is no way to verify a statement, there is no way to test it and prove whether it is right or wrong.

“Wisdom” is one’s ability to apply knowledge adroitly in our daily lives to strengthen our survival chances. Eventually, the knowledge we gather through validations must empower us. It must broaden our perception of the truth and facilitate rational decisions. If not, we cannot make our lives joyful. Hence, good action with devotion must follow all the learning.

Individuals advance at their pace towards a state of perfectibility in character without any vices that we can call godliness. They become virtuous gradually over the years by continually acquiring knowledge. Education is the real baptism that children undergo that makes them humane and classless. Thereafter, all the artificial barriers erected to divide us perish.

Since our consciousness is at different levels of evolution at any time, it is impossible to establish a utopia free from vices. It is crucial to realize this, as millions are yet to recover from the scars of an attempt to create one. A better world is achievable only if every individual aspires to a happier life for themselves without becoming a hurdle to the happiness of others. In addition, everyone must trust in their volition to achieve it.

Virtuous living is a secure investment that we undertake to eliminate future threats to our existence. It may increase survival and result in pleasure. On the other hand, vices result in pain, as it only hurts survival prospects. Bad karma always has a way of coming back to haunt us. So, it has become a prerequisite to our thriving that we engage reasonably.